FAIR sums up five Latter-day Saint scholars' criticisms of Grant Palmer's book An Insider's View.

Date
2026
Type
Website
Source
FAIR
LDS
Hearsay
Secondary
Reference

"A Summary of Five Reviews of Grant Palmer’s “An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins” (with a Few Comments of My Own)," FAIR Latter-day Saints, accessed June 17, 2026

Scribe/Publisher
FAIR
People
Mark Ashurst-McGee, James B. Allen, Louis Midgley, Davis Bitton, Grant H. Palmer, Steven C. Harper, FAIR
Audience
Reading Public
Transcription

No, Grant, that’s not history–and it was certainly not written with “…balanced scholarship and academic integrity.”

This pretty well sums up the central theme of five different scholarly reviews of Grant H. Palmer’s book, An Insider’s View of Mormon Origins. The purpose of this article is not to duplicate the existing reviews and answer the many objections to Palmer’s book, but to summarize and point to the five reviews as a source for the answers. The five reviews are:

- “Trustworthy History?” written by Steven C. Harper and found in FARMS Review (Vol. 15, Issue 2). Steven C. Harper (Ph.D., Lehigh University) is assistant professor of Church history and doctrine at Brigham Young University. This review identifies many sources, scholars and issues that Palmer simply ignores. Harper focuses primarily on how Palmer manipulates evidence regarding Mormon origins.

- “The Charge of a Man with a Broken Lance (But Look What He Doesn’t Tell Us)” written by Davis Bitton and found in FARMS Review (Vol. 15, Issue 2). Davis Bitton (Ph.D., Princeton University) is Professor Emeritus of History at the University of Utah and served for ten years as assistant Church historian. This review identifies sources, scholars, and issues that Palmer simply ignores.

- “Prying into Palmer” written by Louis Midgley and found in FARMS Review (Vol. 15, Issue 2). Louis C. Midgley (Ph.D., Brown University) is Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Brigham Young University. In his review, Midgley looks at the history of the writing of this book and Palmer’s employment history with the Church Education System. He also effectively debunks Palmer’s assertions concerning parallels between the book The Golden Pot and Joseph Smith’s history.

- “A One-sided View of Mormon Origins” written by Mark Ashurst-McGee and found in FARMS Review (Vol. 15, Issue 2). Mark Ashurst-McGee is a graduate student at Arizona State University and is an associate editor of the Papers of Joseph Smith at the Joseph Fielding Smith Institute for Latter-day Saint History. He won the Reese Award for the best thesis in Mormon History in 2001 for his work on Joseph Smith. In this review Ashurst-McGee looks at Palmer’s primary points and responds to each argument showing that conclusions supporting Joseph Smith are entirely reasonable and usually more so than Palmer’s assertions.

- “Asked and Answered: A Response to Grant H. Palmer” written by James B. Allen and found in FARMS Review (Vol. 16, Issue 1). James B. Allen (Ph.D., University of Southern California) is professor of history emeritus, senior research fellow, Joseph Fielding Smith Institute for Latter-Day Saint History at Brigham Young University, and former assistant Church historian. In this review, Allen looks at Palmer’s book as a believing scholar. He considers many of the points Palmer’s tries to make and shows that a believing perspective is just as valid as a doubting viewpoint. He persuasively suggests that all of the various points that Palmer brings up have already been “asked and answered.” A shorter version of this review is found in BYU Studies (Vol. 42, Issue 2).

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.