Robert A. Rees argues Joseph Smith did not have the literary skill to write the Book of Mormon himself.

Date
2002
Type
Academic / Technical Report
Source
Robert A. Rees
LDS
Hearsay
Secondary
Reference

Robert A. Rees, "Joseph Smith, the Book of Mormon, and the American Renaissance," Dialogue vol. 35, no. 3, 2002, 89-91

Scribe/Publisher
Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought
People
Robert A. Rees, Joseph Smith, Jr., Harold Bloom
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

Literary Imagination and Talent

The highest species of reasoning upon divine subjects is. . .the fruit of a sort of moral imagination.

Emerson, Journal, 18 April 1824

Blessed are those who have no talent.

Emerson, Journal, February 1850

While many critics disagree about Joseph Smith’s character, there is almost universal agreement that he had an unusually creative and energetic imagination. Fawn Brodie wrote that “the rare quality of his genius was due not to his reason but to his imagination. He was a mythmaker of prodigious talent.”[17] Harold Bloom, one of the preeminent humanistic scholars of our generation, has praised him as having an “extraordinary capacity for speculative development.”[18] Yet, what we know of Joseph Smith at the time he produced the Book of Mormon reveals no proclivity for artistic expression. That he was imaginative there is no doubt, but that he had the ability write a five hundred-page fictional narrative there is substantial doubt. There is an enormous difference between being able to conceive of something imaginatively and being able to shape it into a unified, complex, and concrete artifact. Many of us may think of wonderful novels we would like to write or symphonies we would like to compose, but only those with true gifts are able to produce novels or symphonies.

Was Joseph Smith a gifted creative writer? Did he have narrative or fictional capabilities similar to those of contemporaries such as Cooper, Melville, or Hawthorne? Did he have any poetic ability like Emerson’s, Lowell’s, or Whitman’s? Was he a lesser literary light like John Neal or William Gilmore Simms? Or could he, in fact, be placed even in this later category of writers?

Although Harold Bloom praises Joseph Smith’s charisma and imagination, he sees him as “an indifferent writer.”[19] Smith achieves moments of eloquence and was beginning to develop a mature writing style by the time he was martyred, but none of his own writings indicate either the narrative style or poetic complexity found in the Book of Mormon. Richard Rust observes, “I have spent a good deal of time reading the journals and letters of Joseph Smith, and I consider his style to differ markedly from the style (really, the styles) I find in the Book of Mormon.”[20] The word-print studies by Hilton, Larson, Rencher, and Layton point to markedly different styles among Book of Mormon writers. Not everyone is convinced by their findings,[21] but whether the word-print analysts are convincing or not, there is no disputing the fact that there are a number of strikingly different authorial voices in the Book of Mormon. To invent these would be an extremely challenging task, especially for a novice writer creating the entire narrative orally, as Joseph Smith’s scribes describe him as doing.

Consider what this would have involved: to compose the various narratives within the Book of Mormon orally, Joseph Smith would have had to keep in mind the distinctive rhetorical style and vocabulary of each character. This would mean mentally cataloguing and tracking each writer or speaker’s way of expressing himself. For example, since Alma the Younger has by far the largest vocabulary in the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith would have had to be aware that he was putting a number of words into Alma’s mouth that he could not employ in the vocabulary of any other writer! Even had he had a photographic memory and been a brilliant novelist, I don’t believe he could have kept this sorted out as he was dictating the book.

I contend that not only was the composition of the Book of Mormon far beyond Joseph Smith’s capabilities, but that he was, in fact, unaware of the subtleties and complexities of the text. There is surely no evidence that he knew anything about writing intricate parallel literary structures or creating a wide range of characters, a complicated fictional plot, or a variety of styles. Again quoting from Harold Bloom, Joseph Smith’s “life, personality, and visions far transcended his talents at the composition of divine texts.”[22]

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.