Schmidt, Wilhelmy, and Gross write that retrospective diagnosis must be heavily scrutinized, and should only be done following rigorous methods.
Mathias Schmidt, Saskia Wilhelmy, and Dominik Gross, "Retrospective diagnosis of mental illness: past and present," The Lancet Psychiatry 7, no. 1 (January 2020): 14–17, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(19)30287-1, accessed May 1, 2026
The task of historians is to reconstruct past events to the highest degree of accuracy, and thus make use of traditional sources (ie, letters and personnel files) and contemporary illustrations. Medical historians are often limited in their efforts, especially in historiography of ill persons and reconstruction of their diseases. This limitation applies especially to mental illnesses, as some disorders cannot be objectified using laboratory parameters. In many cases of mental illness, little was known about their ontogenesis. . . . This absence of knowledge makes retrospective diagnoses difficult and susceptible to speculation, rumours, and conspiracy theories. . . .
. . . Mental illnesses should be seen as social constructions. For example, what was considered as a psychiatric disorder in the past (eg, homosexuality) is nowadays considered a norm variant, and some disorders have no equivalent past disorder. In other words, medical knowledge is socially and culturally transformed. Thus, projection of disease categories and definitions into the past is an inadmissible simplification and an anachronism. For example, post-traumatic stress disorder cannot be projected into the past when terms such as shell shock, thousand-yard stare, combat fatigue, or combat stress reaction were used in connection with war trauma. At best, we can draw parallels without equating; otherwise the past would be changed retroactively. An example in this context are soldiers who deserted in the First World War and are diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder retroactively. This approach is not possible because the concept of post-traumatic stress disorder is based on existing clinical and research developments.
Finally, written texts cannot be regarded as objective sources, but should be considered in terms of their subjectivity (pronounced in so-called ego documents, such as letters and autobiographies). Most historical documents were compiled for reasons other than those that interest modern researchers, in humanities and sciences alike. Standards of proof were also subtly different, especially when diagnosing and treating mental disorders. . . .
Medical information in historical sources should not be simplified or instrumentalised. Modern-day medical pronouncements on the state of mind of historical persons are mostly characterised by three general characteristics. First, medical statements are often unscientific because they suggest historical accuracy that does not exist. Diagnoses are constructed and sometimes based on sources of authors who deliberately wanted to convey a specific image of a person. Therefore, doctors and historians should self-critically scrutinise retrospective diagnoses. No physician should make a diagnosis without examining the person concerned, especially if no medical records or medical data are available. The American Psychiatric Association explicitly requires this approach in The Goldwater Rule (1973): “it is unethical for a psychiatrist to offer a professional opinion unless he or she has conducted an examination and has been granted proper authorisation for such a statement”. Similarly, every historian is required not to rely uncritically on memory reports and memoirs from contemporary witnesses. No physician or historian should fall short of these professional standards. Second, statements might be one-dimensional because they try to explain multicausal historical developments in a monocausal way, reducing complex social interdependencies. Third, medical statements can also be morally questionable and irresponsible, especially if they provide simple explanations for far-reaching political events. . . .
Psychiatry and history work best in diagnosis when they apply rigorously the optimal methods of both disciplines, and physicians and historians should be aware of their responsibilities.