Brian C. Hales rejects Robert Beckstead et al.'s findings about Joseph Smith's possible use of hallucinogenic drugs.

Date
Jan 1, 2020
Type
Academic / Technical Report
Source
Brian C. Hales
LDS
Hearsay
Secondary
Reference

Brian C. Hales, "Visions, Mushrooms, Fungi, Cacti, and Toads: Joseph Smith’s Visions, Mushrooms, Fungi, Cacti, and Toads: Joseph Smith’s Reported Use of Entheogens Reported Use of Entheogens," Interpreter: A Journal of Latter-day Saint Faith and Interpreter: A Journal of Latter-day Saint Faith and Scholarship vol. 38, January 2020, 353-354

Scribe/Publisher
Interpreter: A Journal of Latter-day Saint Faith and Scholarship
People
Brian C. Hales, Robert Beckstead et al., Joseph Smith, Jr.
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

EOMWH [Robert Beckstead et al.'s article] discusses a few events and presents a sufficient number of historical facts to imply a connection to hallucinogens (238–42), but the idiom "the devil is in the details" applies. The simplistic descriptions of the religious behaviors outlined in the EOMWH do not explain what would have been a very complex process if those activities were caused by entheogens. While a few accusations of intoxication can be found from critics (223, 238, 241), no historical report from friend or foe includes details that trace the intoxication to any chemical or drug previously consumed, except perhaps ethanol. More importantly, the sensations felt at onset and the durations of potentially many hours, not to men tion the variable psychotropic influences the visionaries would have experienced (including bad trips), hardly correlate to the faith-promoting manifestations reported in multiple accounts from believers.

. . .

Conclusion

EOMWH presents an interesting theory that the visionary experiences of Joseph Smith and the early Saints resulted from entheogenic ingestion. Sustaining this view, the authors present general observations and a few selected reports along with many conjectures.

The idea that Joseph Smith was a highly advanced herbalist and mycologist who could correctly distinguish psychedelic mushrooms and from death caps and then appropriately prepare the entheogens to obtain the expected hallucinations is historically unsupported. The learning curve to obtain such expertise for most of the seven entheogens would be steep and time-consuming. Overall, there is no evidence that mushrooms, cacti, other plants, or toad secretions were sought, harvested, prepared, or consumed by the first generation of believers or any thereafter.

An additional concern is that the psychedelic influences of drugs like psilocybin, mescaline, and 5-MeO-DMT are very different from the extra-worldly experiences mentioned by early Latter-day Saints that were described as faith-promoting and uplifting. It is likely that Joseph Smith would have condemned many of the behaviors arising from entheogen ingestion as intoxication.

A growing trend among secularists is to provide naturalistic explanations for religious phenomena. Claims that exogenous chemicals can duplicate the spiritual experiences described by religionists remain unverifiable, because spiritual sensations are so personal to the individual. However, as a believer and researcher who has read multiple accounts describing entheogen effects, I detect remarkable differences.

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.