Brian C. Hales concludes that the creation of the Book of Mormon has similarities with automatic writing but that doesn't account for its origin.

Date
2019
Type
Academic / Technical Report
Source
Brian C. Hales
LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Brian C. Hales, "Automatic Writing and the Book of Mormon An Update," Dialogue Summer 2019, 34

Scribe/Publisher
Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought
People
Brian C. Hales, Joseph Smith, Jr.
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
PDF
PDF
Transcription

Conclusion

In conclusion, the similarities between the creation of the Book of Mormon and other automatic writings are undeniable. While automatic writing has been promoted as “the best model for understanding the translation of the Book of Mormon,” the apparent connection does not constitute an actual explanation of how these compositions were generated.[130] Grouping the Book of Mormon with automatic writing provides no answer to the question, “Where did all the words come from?”

Secularists will understandably reject Joseph Smith’s revelations describing different types of supernatural forces influencing both the creation of the Book of Mormon and automatic writings. Even as psychological explanations attribute the words to the subconscious minds of the authors, prospective experiments demonstrating this to be a possibility have yet to be performed. Neither have assumptions that entering a trance state could enhance the natural compositional abilities of the authors been proven. Indeed, available scientific studies appear to demonstrate the opposite.

These observations might explain the reason why, historically, automatic writing has never gained wide acceptance among naturalistic theories explicating the origin of the Book of Mormon. It appears that Joseph Smith’s intellectual qualifications in 1829, the complexity of the Book of Mormon, the difficulties of creative dictation, and the inherent cognitive limitations of an unconscious state fail to coalesce into a plausible explanation of how he generated all the words. Nevertheless, the findings presented in this article should not be considered the final word; additional research is warranted to explain Joseph Smith’s loquaciousness even if automatic writing is insufficient to do so.

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.