Isaac Woodbridge Riley claims Joseph Smith had epilepsy and produced the Book of Mormon through automatic writing.

Date
1902
Type
Book
Source
Isaac Woodbridge Riley
Critic
Non-LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

I. Woodbridge Riley, The Founder of Mormonism: A Psychological Study of Joseph Smith, Jr. (New York: Dodd, Mead & Co., 1902), p. 3–4, 73–74, 84–85, 350

Scribe/Publisher
Dodd, Mead & Company
People
Tiberius Julius Caesar Augustus, Isaac Woodbridge Riley, Solomon Mack, Joseph Smith, Jr., Napoleon Bonaparte
Audience
Reading Public
Transcription

To read the flux of books on the founder of Mormonism, one might think there were no middle course between vilification and deification. To sectarians Joseph Smith appears an ignoramus, a fanatic, an impostor, and a libertine; to his followers—a prophet, a seer, a vicegerent of God, and a martyr. While two generations of writers have been presenting Smith's character in its mental and moral extremes, they have been ignoring the all-important physical basis of his personality. If a solution of his perplexing individuality is wanted, the pathological grounds must be examined. The state of his body goes far to explain the state of his mind, and his ancestry to explain both. Like the distorted views of his grandfather 'Crook-necked Smith' [Solomon Mack] Joseph's mental abnormalities are to be connected with physical ills.

. . .

It is more than a coincidence that the boy's [Joseph Smith's] strange actions, while working in the field, precisely correspond to one of those epileptic attacks designated vacuity. Elsewhere is given a fuller examination of the rest of Joseph's seizures. The psychic premonitions and the physical after-effects, from the delirium of persecution to the dislocation of the thumb,—all are accounted for under the supposition of epilepsy. It is no forced analogy; the details attach themselves to the scheme as naturally as barnacles to a rock.

To explain Joseph's more abnormal experiences, one must rest content with epilepsy as a working hypothesis. Yet, as such, it binds together a further series of otherwise irrelated facts: through it both ancestry and progeny fall in line. Looking backward to the first generation there is antecedent probability in the grandfather's [Solomon Mack's] 'fits' on Winchester Hills; looking forward there is corroboration in the circumstance that 'fits' have reappeared in the fifth generation. But confining attention to the life of the prophet: although he stood midway in atavistic line of neuropathics, that was no bar to later health and strength. The long intervals between his seizures, and their cessation at about twenty-one, point to one of the more favored cases of spontaneous cure. Of his mental robustness the same may be said. It is going too high to cite the tradition of epileptics such as Cæsar and Napoleon, since epilepsy vulgarly and commonly may exist in an absolutely healthy state of mind. Contrary to the opinion of some alienists, there is statistical proof the epilepsy does not always lead to mental disorders. So on the one hand, the attenuated form of Joseph's case and the infrequency of his youthful attacks, and on the other his many successful enterprises, especially the management of his cantankerous followers, preclude the idea of absolute mental deterioration.

. . .

At the time, young Smith doubtless believed in the supernatural origins of his transcript [of the Book of Mormon]. The reason for this was that it was written under more or less unconscious conditions. The man who first saw it almost hit the nail on the head when he said such characters could be produced if one were to shut up his eyes. As will be seen, the paper bears marks of being written under the influence of veritable crystal gazing. In that self-induced, trance-like state Joseph's involuntary scratchings would appear to him occult, mysterious, true revelations from heaven. For a scientific explanation of the matter there is no need to call in the activities of a 'second personality,' but merely those of the subconscious self. The scrawl is analogous to the scribblings of the undeveloped automatically-writing hand, such as is found even among the uncivilized. If the ultimate solution of this document is a problem for abnormal psychology, its make up is no great mystery. As the contents of the Book of Mormon can be traced to indigenous sources—the ideas which Joseph picked up in the Indian country where he lived—so it is with these characters. The more elaborate resemble the picture writing of the aborigines, such as would interest a boy. It is going too far to hunt for Greek and Hebrew letters, for the tables of foreign alphabets had not yet appeared in current dictionaries. The job is home-made: if Joseph had not taken the matter so seriously, this might be considered an amusing burlesque on a farmer's almanac, for he has only half concealed the signs of the Zodiac and those cabalistic aspects and nodes which may go with the planting of potatoes.

. . .

Before further examination of Joseph's neuropathic antecedents, and in order to complete the tale of the generations, a word may be said concerning his progeny. From sources which cannot here be divulged, comes the significant fact that 'fits' have reappeared, not in the fourth, but in the fifth generation. The atavism in the prophet's case is clear: he stands midway in the series. As to the causes productive of the epileptic tendency, heredity has its acknowledged primacy.

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.