Harry M. Beardsley claims Joseph Smith had dementia præcox (schizophrenia), which helped him produce the Book of Mormon.
Harry M. Beardsley, Joseph Smith And His Mormon Empire (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1931), 80–87
Its [the Solomon Spaulding Theory's] promulgators fail to prove that either Smith or Rigdon ever had the Spaulding manuscript in their possession. . . .
The true story probably follows more closely the pattern of the Mormon version than that of its detractors, but if we relate it in modern terms, it is shorn of its supernatural aspect: the idea of The Book of Mormon appears to have been a gradual evolution. The early stories of Joe and his parents regarding his visions as cited by Lewis, Lapham, Ingersoll, and Chase, in Chapter VI, trace this evolution clearly: Captain Kidd became 'a Spaniard,' the Spaniard became a messenger of God; a buried treasure became a golden book; the golden book became a 'Golden Bible.' Joe learned of the Urim and Thummim through his Bible-reading, or through Rigdon, and recognized them as a great improvement over his peekstone. The peekstone became the Urim and Thummim. Joe would put the stone into his hat and retire behind the curtain, while Harris, Emma, or Cowdery waited with pencil poised on the other side. With his face buried deep in the crow of the hat, the seer would gaze steadily at the stone, until his eyes grew weary from the strain, his eyelids drooped, a grateful languor possessed him. Strange sounds were wafted to his ears; in the stone strange pictures formed and faded.
Then the Prophet would being to speak, slowly, distinctly, a syllable at a time. His amanuensis jotted the syllables down in awe. It was the voice of Joe that came from beyond the curtain, but to Harris and Cowdery it seemed that the words were the words of God. Emma, apparently, was not so sure. Joe might be a prophet of God to some; to her, he was just a lazy husband. She wished he would quit his foolishness and settle down to the business of providing a living for his family.
——
The Book of Mormon is a product of an adolescent mind and a mind characterized by the symptoms of the most prevalent mental diseases of adolescence — dementia præcox. By the time the book was completed, Joe had emerged from adolescence into maturity and the nature of his disease had been modified. He was never to recover from it completely, but, like thousands of other dementia præcox victims, was to climb to high places, despite his affliction. Woodbridge Riley diagnosed Smith as an epileptic, and cited his visions, those of his mother and of his grandparents, Asahel Smith and Solomon Mack, as evidence that both branches of his ancestry suffered from the same general type of affliction.
Certainly Joe's visions were accompanied by seizers which, from his accounts, appear to have been epileptic. Riley notes that during his twenty-third year, and thereafter, Joe underwent certain changes and, apparently, was automatically cured. This is a course which is frequently followed by the milder forms of epilepsy. The brilliant lights accompanying the visions are characteristic of epileptic seizures. The buffetings administered by the frog which sprang out of the box and assumed the form of a man, and the maulings at the hands of Satan and his minions which Joe reports, are also characteristic. Riley's diagnosis is convincing on the epileptic side, but he gives no intimation that the epilepsy was accompanied by dementia præcox.
What is dementia præcox? Dr. Smith Ely Jelliffe, distinguished psychiatrist, writing on the subject in The Encyclopædia Americana says:
'Dementia præcox is a term used in psychiatry to designate a disorder group characterized by certain types of mental deterioration or disintegration. This term originated with Kraeplin, professor of Psychiatry at Munich. Clouston of Scotland defined the disorder as the "insanity of adolescence," and Bleuler of Zurich has used the term "schizophrenia." Thus, from the terms alone, a brief description may be formulated — a mental disorder, chiefly occurring in adolescence or young life, characterized by a splitting of the psyche ("schizo-phrenia") — and usually leading to a precocious dementia or mental breakdown. This mental disorder is the most frequent of all of the psychoses, constituting fully 30 per cent of the admissions to hospitals for mental diseases....
'The chief feature that characterizes dementia præcox is the tendency for the patient to make use of autistic thinking. That is, the individual withdraws his interest from the external world (introverts) and constructs a phantasy world into which he tends to withdraw more and more. At first, this type of thinking detaches him only partially from the world of reality. He is able to come out of his day-dreaming, as it were, but, as the introversion of his phantasy life becomes more and more pronounced, the splitting between his phantasy world and the real world becomes too great to be bridged.
'The early stages are marked by a lack of interest taken by the potential schizophrenic in his surroundings ... there is a failure of voluntary attention and lack of sociability. In this stage many take up a tramp or hobo existence.... Depressions, or silly conduct, may mark the gradual development of these breakdowns. The ideas which some express become more and more bizarre. They frequently hear voices and are having telepathic communications. Some of these patients believe themselves clairvoyants; can read the stars or what people are thinking.
'The paranoid forms seem to come off best in their conflicts. They split least, as it were, they construct a fairly logical system of defense. They find an external cause for their internal wishes and by this projection mechanism are able to get along fairly well in the social world. Many inventors, reformers, religious zealots, quacks, litigious and vindictive individuals approach this group, or slide into it in varying degrees. Most frequently the delusional attitudes are sexually colored. The most common is that certain men or women are following them or conspiring against them to ruin or degrade them. Various secret societies are banded against them, cliques and political parties are hampering their activities. Many of this type are rarely recognized by the layman as being sick. They are often thought of as difficult people to get along with, especially to the family circle, but to the average outsider they are rarely considered sick. They may even occupy important positions in the community and yet be severely sick.'
Taking the symptoms as noted by Dr. Jelliffe, we find Joe in his teens, lived in a phantasy world; 'Taciturnity was one of his characteristics. He seldom spoke unless spoken to' — [Orsamus] Turner. Joe and his father wandered back and forth across the states of New York and Pennsylvania for ten years. 'He would utter the most palpable exaggerations with apparent gravity' — Turner. Joe heard voices, had visions, communicated with God. His money-digging ventures were all accompanied by pretensions of clairvoyant powers. Joe's revelations always gave him divine authority for doing something he wished to do or to have done. The polygamy doctrine resulted from the sexual interest. Mother Smith's book and Joe's journals abound with expressions of their respective persecution complexes. The first of Joe's schizophrenic tendencies to develop was his day-dreaming; with the discovery of his peekstone, this developed into crystal-gazing. Crystal-gazing may be likened to a voluntarily induced schizophrenia. The gazer, through physical and psychic stimuli induced by concentrating his gaze upon the crystal or any bright object, produces a 'split' in his personality. The normal personality is lulled temporarily to sleep. In its stead, one, or several personalities, all different from the normal personality and different from each other, may emerge. Automatic writers, operators of Ouija boards, and spiritualistic mediums induce themselves into analogous states. Their faculties are seized upon by 'controls' who speak or write through the medium.
. . .
According to David Whitmer, all translations and revelations at first came through the medium of the stone. later, they came 'direct from God' through Joseph's lips. 'He would inquire of the Lord and pray; then announce his reply,' Whitmer stated. 'Sometimes,' he concluded naïvely, 'he was mistaken in the source of the reply.'
In all of these idiomotive processes —divining, automatic writing, crystal-gazing, or spiritualistic trances — the medium is frequently enabled to perform acts of which he or she is incapable in a normal state. A person who cannot draw at all, normally, may produce a fairly creditable drawing while in an autistic state. Mediums may speak in dialects with which they are not normally familiar. The inarticulate or illiterate may be enabled to speak or write with unaccustomed fluency.
Thus, the voice that floated over the curtain in the room at the Hale house, or at the Whitmers', was the voice of Joseph Smith, but it was not under the control of Joseph Smith. Martin Harris thought it was the voice of God. A spiritualist might argue that it was the spirit of the Angel Moroni speaking through Joe. Modern psychologists might say that it was the subconscious personality.
Truly, the workings of this subconscious personality are mysterious; but they are not supernatural. Every word which the subconscious personality emitted through the vocal chords of Joseph Smith, Jr. is explicable to the psychologist could he be provided with the necessary data. Every phrase, every sentence, every idea had an origin somewhere in Joe's past mental experience. The incident which inspired it may have been forgotten, the words or phrases may never have been a part of his conscious vocabulary, yet the subconscious mind had retained them.
The words Joe Smith saw in the crystal and the sentences which they produced may, or may not, have appeared miraculous to him as he read them later from the manuscript, but if he had analyzed them closely, he would have realized that he had reproduced in The Book of Mormon the dreams and visions of Asahel Smith, Solomon Mack, and Lucy Smith. He had heard Mother Smith relate them many times. She related them later in her biography of her son, apparently unaware, that he had presented them but slightly altered in The Book of Mormon. He reproduced here, too, snatches of The Bible, snatches of the talk he had heard at the Sabine farm about the Spaulding story, snatches of sermons and theological discussions overheard around the stoves of village stores and about the family fireside. Riley dismisses the Spaulding-Rigdon theory as untenable, stating that the Indian lore bears the local color of the Palmyra region of Joe's period rather than of the period and locality in which Spaulding wrote. The early anti-Mormon critics assumed that it was necessary for Joe actually to have possessed the Spaulding manuscript and to have copied it almost verbatim. They went to great lengths to prove possession, but without success. But possession of the manuscript would not have been essential. Joe had ample opportunity to hear the Spaulding story discussed, and these discussions might easily have been retained by his conscious, or subconscious memory, and so become a part of the background of Indian lore to which Riley refers. Joe's biblical lore was so colored through his interpretation of The Bible in terms of his own experiences and environment as to acquire a distinct Josephian flavor. It is reasonable to suppose that Spaulding's story might have suffered a similar distortion. Thus, while the Spaulding theory is not necessary to explain the origin of The Book of Mormon, Spaulding's story may well have been, if not the nucleus of the book, at least the subconscious inspiration for it.
In the same way, acquaintanceship between Rigdon and Joe is not necessary to explain the theology of The Book of Mormon. True, the theology bears evidence of Rigdon's parentage, and events which transpired soon after publication of the book tend to confirm one's suspicion of that paternity. Rigdon's ideas, however, were not unique. They were an outgrowth of the times, and other preachers and laymen reacted to the times in much the same fashion as Rigdon did. Men in various parts of the country were thinking along much the same lines. It is not improbable that Joe and Sidney might have extracted from the same jumbled background of religious ferment the same general conclusions and convictions.
The Book of Mormon reveals the background of western New York of the first decades of the nineteenth century as distorted by an adolescent mind, and as recorded by that mind in an autistic state. The religious and political questions of the period are clearly recognizable. Walter Franklin Pierce [Prince], in Volume 28 of The American Journal of Psychology, points out the similarity between visions reported in The Book of Mormon and those attributed in Mother Smith's biography to her various relatives.
Pierce then shows that Smith's memory and emotion complexes influenced him in inventing proper names to provide the dramatis personæ and the geographical setting for his book. Memory and emotion complexes exert an unconscious influence upon persons in the invention of such na es, Pierce points out, and certain consonantal and vowel sounds will unconsciously be repeated. The anti-Masonic agitation and [William] Morgan's disappearance provided the motif for the nomenclature of The Book of Mormon, Pierce shows. There are frequent references to secret orders and their activities, signs, grips, compacts. Out of forty proper names in the book beginning with the letter 'M,' twenty-five begin with the syllable 'mor' (Morgan).