T. B. H. Stenhouse claims Joseph Smith may have used spiritualism to write the Book of Mormon, doesn't believe Spaulding theory.
T. B. H. Stenhouse, The Rocky Mountain Saints: A Full and Complete History of the Mormons (London: Ward, Lock and Tyler, 1876), 208, 508, accessed December 11, 2025
For some time after the trial, Sidney [Rigdon] showed considerable disposition to fight the position assumed by Brigham and the Twelve, and for that purpose he revived the Latter-day Saints' Messenger and Advocate, in Pittsburg, Pa.; but it had only a short-lived existence. He is now very feeble with age and infirmity, and living in Friendship, New York. It has been generally expected that some day he would confess to having aided Joseph Smith in fabricating, from "Solomon Spaulding's "Manuscript," the Book of Mormon; but there seems to be no ground for such a hope. All through his trial those who knew him before he was a Mormon spoke of him in such a manner as leaves no room to doubt Rigdon's own sincerity in the Mormon faith, and his total ignorance of the existence of Joseph Smith and the Book of Mormon till after that work had been published.
. . .
*The critics state that Joseph had on his side of the curtain the "lost manuscript" of Solomon Spaulding, which he interpolated with extracts from the Old and New Testaments, adding to them his own crude knowledge of Methodism, and thus palmed upon his credulous scribes, Harris and Cowdery, the Book of Mormon. This is the prevailing view of the opponents of Mormonism as to the origin of that book. But it may yet be accepted that Joseph's seclusion behind the curtain with his crystal "interpreters" answers to the dark séances so common in the experience of modern Spiritualism. There is much in Joseph's history to confirm such a theory. He has frequently been charged with pretending to give revelations through a "peep-stone" which he placed in his hat, then putting his face against the hat and excluding all light therefrom, in that manner is aid to have read the language of the heavens. The Author is acquainted with a gentleman who, when he was a boy, was frequently in the company of Joseph at Nauvoo, as his father was very intimate with the Prophet. This gentleman is what is now called clairvoyant, and relates that Joseph frequently put his "Urim and Thummim," "interpreters," or "peep-stones," or whatever else they might be called, into his hat when the boy was visiting him, and by looking upon them as Joseph did, he claims to have had wonderful panoramic visions. There are multitudes of persons throughout the world—many in Utah now—who claim perfect familiarity with this "peep-stone" business, and the better Joseph Smith is known, the nearer he approaches those "gifted persons, and the easier is he understood.