Grant Palmer says Joseph Smith's story about the origins of the Book of Mormon was influenced by Luman Walter's and The Golden Pot.

Date
2002
Type
Book
Source
Grant H. Palmer
LDS
Disaffected
Critic
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Grant H. Palmer, An Insider's View of Mormon Origins (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 2002), 135–144, 170–171, 173–174

Scribe/Publisher
Signature Books
People
Brigham Young, Clark Braden, Alvin Smith, E. T. A. Hoffman, Lorenzo Saunders, Joseph Smith, Jr., Elizabeth Kane, Grant H. Palmer, Luman Walters, Abner Cole, Willard Chase
Audience
Reading Public
Transcription

We have observed how Joseph Smith synthesized material from various sources in a way that was relevant to people of his day. Some of the sources he drew from include the King James Bible, evangelical Protestantism, Masonry, and American antiquities. In this chapter and the next, I will discuss how another element that was prevalent in his environment—popular beliefs about the supernatural—informed his experiences and his interpretation of the world and how these became part of the early narratives about his life.

Many of the American assumptions about supernatural beings and phenomena derived from Old World stories about ancient mines and lost civilizations and their forgotten wisdom. People believed that forest and dale held spirits and hidden treasures that the spirits guarded. A pick and shovel would be insufficient to find and exhume such wonders. An example is found in a popular short story published in Germany in 1814, introduced to America in 1827. Its author, E. T. A. Hoffman, was born in 1776, worked in Bamberg, Dresden, Leipzig, and Warsaw, and died in Berlin in 1822. He wrote about fifty short stories and novellas and is best known today for "The Nutcracker and the Mouse King" and "The Sandman." In his day, one of his most influential stories was "The Golden Pot," notable for the fact that although it involved gold and money, the principle attraction was esoteric knowledge. For our purposes, its parallels to Joseph Smith's experiences are of interest (figs. 27-28).

. . .

. . . After its publication in German, "The Golden Pot" was translated into French and English. The English translation was the work of Thomas Carlisle, who had it published in Edinburgh and London in early 1827 (fig. 29). Within weeks, it was already on bookstore shelves in the United States. Of course, the story was already known in some circles in America through its foreign-language editions, as were others of Hoffman's tales. An advertisement in the Palmyra newspaper in 1827 promoted a literary magazine's critique of Hoffmann's works.

Among Joseph Smith's acquaintances, one in particular would have appreciated the German and French editions of Hoffmann's writings. His name was Luman Walters, of Sodus, Wayne County, New York. That the Smith family had contact with Walters in 1822-23 shortly after his move to Sodus is confirmed by Brigham Young, Lorenzo Saunders, Abner Cole, and others. Sodus was twenty-five miles from Palmyra and thirty miles from Mendon where Brigham Young lived. Young met Walters and described him as "a man of profound learning [who] had put himself in possession of all the learning in the States, had been to France, Germany, Italy, and through the world." Young later told a group in 1873, according to Elizabeth Kane: "A man named Walters[,] son of a rich man ... received a scientific education, was even sent to Paris. After he came home he lived like a misanthrope, he had come back an infidel ..."

Clark Braden, a Campbellite college president in Kirtland, Ohio, said that Walters lived in Europe before he met Joseph Smith. His investigations in Palmyra showed that "[w]hile acting in his primitive, super-natural capacity as water-witch and money-digger, [Joseph] Smith made the acquaintance of a ... Walters, who had been a physician in Europe. This person had learned in Europe the secret of Mesmerism or animal magnetism. This was entirely unknown in America except to a few in large cities ..." This European education in medicine suggests that Walters knew French or German or both.

. . .

Although Walters practiced medicine, he earlier dabbled in the occult and was a "clairvoyant," according to family tradition. Abner Cole reported that he was skilled in the magical arts and conducted treasure digging with Joseph Smith and others at Miner's Hill in Manchester. Cole was interested in these activities because he owned the property at Miner's Hill from 1820 through 1823. He wrote in the Palmyra Reflector on 12 June 1830 that "Walters the Magician, who has strange books, and deals with familiar spirits ... produced an old book in an unknown tongue, ... from whence he read in the presence of the Idle and Slothful [the money diggers]{sic} strange stories of hidden treasures and of the spirit who had the custody thereof." Cole added in a subsequent article that when Walters read, he would "interpret, and explain [the book], as a record of the former inhabitants of America." He believed that Walters must have suggested the idea of a book to Joseph Smith, as did ten Palmyra residents who, although they may have been influenced by Cole, added the weight of their opinion in a letter to the Painesville Telegraph. They said that the "idea of a 'book' was doubtless suggested to the Smiths by one Walters."

One of Joseph Smith's neighbors, Lorenzo Saunders, who also lived close to Miner's Hill (fig. 30), remembered that Walters and the Smiths dug there before Alvin Smith died in late 1823. In Lorenzo's interview with a counselor in the RLDS presiding bishopric, Edmund L. Kelley, Lorenzo said, "I am one of them that saw digging there [Miner's Hill] ... Well I will tell you they did dig; Willard Chase & Alvin, the one that died; they dug before Alvin died." . . . Walters is colorful if nothing else; that he is a probably link between Hoffmann's tale and the Palmyra area is also evident.

. . .

Now I will compare all of these recitals by Joseph Smith, his family, and their acquaintances with E. T. A. Hoffmann's "The Golden Pot." . . .

[Section of alleged parallels]]

. . .

In conclusion, what do these parallels mean? Clearly, there are similar motifs, descriptions, and occasionally the same terminology in both the New York and "Golden Pot" narratives. Moreover, how could Joseph control the many detailed events and descriptions that are clearly beyond his power to duplicate and which are common to both narratives? It would stretch credulity to believe that this could be a coincidence, and I therefore think that a debt is owed to E. T. A. Hoffman and the European traditions for at least some of the details that passed from the Smith family to neighbors and from there to outsiders. . . .

. . .

What I believe from this is that the European beliefs about spirit guardians of wealth and wisdom influenced the early accounts of how the Book of Mormon came to be. The influence must have been from several different direction at once. It must have been that when Joseph's family and acquaintances—some of whom knew Luman Walters, and especially those who had been involved in treasure-seeking ventures—heard that Joseph was translating an ancient record, they heard and interpreted this news with ears tuned to familiar themes. . . .

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.