Robert A. Rees compares Joseph Smith's and other nineteenth century writers' literary careers and education.
Robert A. Rees, "Joseph Smith, the Book of Mormon, and the American Renaissance," Dialogue vol. 35, no. 3, 2002, 91-95
Maturity as a Writer
Until I was twenty five I had no development at all.
- Melville
To produce a mature work of literature, a writer must be seasoned in the craft of literary invention and construction. No masterpiece springs full-blown from the writer’s mind without prior experience in working out style and subject matter. Without exception, Joseph Smith’s contemporary authors produced their major works when they were mature writers. Each writer’s magnum opus was years in the preparing and writing. The works of each author show progressive development from early literary expressions to later master works. In most cases their early works reveal writers attempting to find their voice as well as their subject matter. For example, Emerson’s Nature, as Matthiessen observes, “contains in embryo nearly all his cardinal assumptions,”[23] but the essay is philosophically opaque and stylistically difficult. Although Hawthorne’s early style “shows remarkable finish,”[24] the contrast between his first novel, Fanshaw (1828), and The Scarlet Letter (1851) is dramatic. Whitman’s early journalistic writing reveals only the vaguest promise of the powerful poetry that he would later produce. In fact, it wasn’t until he read Emerson’s comments on the first edition of Leaves of Grass (1855) that he seemed to fully realize his vocation as a poet. As he later said, “I was simmering, simmering, simmering; Emerson brought me to a boil.”[25]
By way of comparison, we have only two minor, extant examples of Joseph Smith’s writings before 1830, the year the Book of Mormon was published—a letter to Oliver Cowdery and a one-paragraph introduction to the Anthon Transcript.[26] Neither shows promise of literary expression. There is no evidence before 1830 that Smith was developing as a writer or that he had any ambitions as an author. The material written in the years immediately following the publication of the Book of Mormon shows Joseph Smith as a writer with little literary style or polish. Certainly there is evidence of the beginnings of an eloquent voice, but that voice is tentative and immature. Nowhere in Joseph Smith’s early writing does one find the kind of literary ability necessary to write a book which has since been translated into more languages and sold more copies than any book written by his illustrious contemporaries.
By comparison, we might point out that Nathaniel Hawthorne had been working on The Scarlet Letter for twenty-five years before it was actually published. That is, most of the themes, character types, and situations in his novel were developed to one extent or another in the notes, sketches, and stories Hawthorne wrote between 1825 and 1850. As to the actual time of the writing of the novel, Arlin Turner notes that by the end of August 1849, Hawthorne “was writing immensely, so his wife phrased it.”[27] Typically, Hawthorne would put in nine hours a day at his desk. He wrote his friend Horatio Bridge that the book had been finished on 3 February 1850, making a total of more than five months’ time for the novel’s composition.
Critics speak of Melville’s “try works,” the works of fiction he wrote that prepared him to write Moby Dick. His previous novels of the sea, Mardi, Omoo, Typee, Redburn, and White Jacket, were all novels in which he was working out both his subject matter and his style. Moby Dick, which took him more than eighteen months to complete, reveals indebtedness to all of these earlier works. Melville, whose education, both formal and experiential, was far superior to Joseph Smith’s, said, “My development has all been within a few years past. . . .Until I was twenty five I had no development at all.”[28] In other words, at the same age at which Joseph Smith wrote a book as ambitious as Moby Dick, Melville—recognized as one of the literary masters of American literature—was just beginning to feel confident as a writer, and Moby Dick was still far in the future.
Henry David Thoreau spent nearly nine years writing Walden. Here again, Thoreau’s early writing both prepared him for and contained many of the ideas and themes of his major opus. Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote nothing as sustained as the Book of Mormon, but his essays, which represent his major contribution to the literary age that bears his name, were produced over a lifetime. Walt Whitman wrote and rewrote his great collection of poems, Leaves of Grass, over his entire adult life, seeing it through many permutations and numerous editions.
Thus, each of these authors was significantly older and more mature as a writer when he published his literary masterpiece than was Joseph Smith when he produced the Book of Mormon. Emerson was thirty-eight when his first volume of essays was published, Thoreau was thirty-seven when he published Walden, Hawthorne was thirty-six when The Scarlet Letter was published, and Melville thirty-two when Moby Dick appeared. Whitman was thirty-six when he sent an autographed first edition of Leaves of Grass to Emerson.
Time
Time is but the stream I go a-fishing in.
- Thoreau, Walden
Writers know that writing takes time. As Donald Hall, one of our most venerated contemporary poets says, “It’s typical for me to spend three to five years on a poem, but not working on it every day but maybe every day for six months, then nothing for six months, then starting it again. At the beginning, every draft changes a lot, but toward the end I may spend a lot of time changing a word from the end of one line to the beginning of the next. . . .There are several poems I’ve worked on over twenty years.”[29]
In an article entitled “For Authors, Fragile Ideas Need Loving Every Day,” the novelist Walter Mosley speaks of the importance of a routinized, disciplined approach to writing. Arguing that writing is a quotidian endeavor, Mosley says that interruptions and distractions (which Joseph Smith experienced in abundance during the translation of the Book of Mormon) cause the life to drain out of one’s writing: “The words have no art to them; you no longer remember the smell. The idea seems weak, it has dissipated like smoke.” He adds, “Nothing we create is art at first. It’s simply a collection of notions that may never be understood. Returning every day thickens the atmosphere. Images appear. Connections are made. But even these clearer notions will fade if you stay away more than a day.. . .The act of writing is a kind of guerrilla warfare; there is no vacation, no leave, no relief. In actuality there is very little chance of victory. You are. . .likely to be defeated by your fondest dreams.”[30]
Most writers recognize that good writing is seldom easy and rarely flows seamlessly from the writer’s pen or keyboard—and certainly not in unprepared or unrehearsed dictation. The more complicated, complex and sophisticated the text, the more time it takes to compose. While some writers speak of writing mellifluously flowing lines as if under a spell, in reality, this seldom happens, and if it does, it doesn’t last. When asked about the place of impulse or inspiration in writing poetry, Hall states, “It’s twenty seconds of impulse and two years of attention.”[31]
How much time did Joseph Smith have to write the Book of Mormon? This much is part of the historical record: After losing the first 116 pages of the book through Martin Harris’s negligence, Joseph did not resume his work of translation until 22 September 1828, although he seems to have written little until Oliver Cowdrey became his scribe on 5 April 1829. Between that date and 11 June 1829 (the day Joseph applied for a copyright), a period of approximately sixty days, Joseph and Oliver completed the bulk of the translation. By any measure, this was an astonishing accomplishment. As a straight work of translation or inspired dictation, this would be a formidable task.
Scholars have pointed out that during the time he was translating the book, Joseph Smith was plagued with numerous mundane concerns—finding work, feeding his family, protecting the plates, burying a still-born child, etc. In other words, there were so many stresses and strains that, for the most part, sustained daily writing would have been out of the question.
The Book of Mormon is a complicated narrative with many twists, turns, returns, foreshadowings, and archetypes; numerous kinds of parallelism, including extensive and complicated chiasmi and complex poetic forms; and many different styles. This is not the kind of book one dashes off in a few months as one might a romance novel. This kind of writing takes time and lots of it.
Education
Books are for the scholar's idle times. When he can read God directly, the hour is too precious to be wasted in other men's transcripts of their readings.
Emerson, "The American Scholar"
The authors of the American Renaissance had educations vastly superior to Joseph Smith's. Hawthorne graduated from Bowdin and Emerson and Thoreau from Harvard. Melville attended Albany Academy , and Whitman, although having only about six years of formal education, was a school teacher and for many years engaged in various aspects of journalism, including reporting, writing, and editing. In addition, all were intimately involved in the cultural life of their communities, attending lyceums and concerts, lecturing, publishing and, with the exception of Thoreau (who said that he had traveled much in Concord), traveling far beyond their local environs. This is a stark contrast to the education and culture of Joseph Smith. His formal education was limited to only a few years of schooling, and that, most likely, involved sporadic attendance. In his earliest history (1832), Smith summarized his education: "We [the nine smith children] were deprived of the bennifit of an education suffice it to say I was mearly instructid in reading and writing and the ground [rules] of arithmatic which constuted my whole literary acquirements" (spelling and punctuation in the original).
For the writers of the American Renaissance, not only is there evidence of early composition that prepared and influenced their masterpieces, but there is ample evidence that they benefited from belonging to a literary culture, one full of cross-fertilization. Emerson's influence on Thoreau and Whitman is well documented, as is Hawthorne's on Melville, and vice versa. Although Emerson's shadow on the age is the longest, Emerson himself reveals and acknowledges indebtedness to a number of writers including Swedenborg, Carlyle, Coleridge, and Goethe.
Like Joseph Smith, all of the writers of the American Renaissance were influenced by the King James Bible, and all of their works have allusions to that sacred text and reflect biblical style although none of their works reveals the depth and sophistication of biblical indebtedness that characterizes the Book of Mormon. However, Joseph Smith shows no influence at all from the writers, historical or contemporary, European or American, who served as models for the writers of the American Renaissance. There are no allusions in his writings or in the Book of Mormon to such important writers and thinkers of American culture as Cotton Mather, Edward Taylor, Jonathan Edwards, John Neal, James Fenimore Cooper, Charles Brockden Brown, Washington Irving, or even the more popular writers of the time who were, as David S. Reynolds says, "part of a heterogeneous culture which had strong elements of the criminal, the erotic, and the demonic."