Klaus J. Hansen says epilepsy and automatic writing theories for Joseph Smith are unlikely, comments on "bicameral" and schizophrenia framework for Joseph Smith.

Date
1981
Type
Book
Source
Klaus J. Hansen
LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Klaus J. Hansen, Mormonism and the American Experience (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1981), 16, 18–21

Scribe/Publisher
University of Chicago Press
People
Isaac Woodbridge Riley, Klaus J. Hansen, Julian Jaynes, Joseph Smith, Jr., Oliver Cowdery
Audience
Reading Public
Transcription

The major portion of the Book of Mormon, likewise, was produced in an astoundingly short time, being completed ninety days after Oliver Cowdery started taking dictation from the prophet. This amounts to a production of about three thousand words a day, leading I. Woodbridge Riley to the speculation that the Book of Mormon was the result of automatic writing induced by epilepsy. Any suggestion, however, that Smith may have suffered from such a disease has been discredited. As the experiments by William Butler Yeats and others suggests, however, epilepsy is no necessary precondition for automatic writing. Nevertheless, the length of the work, requiring a consistent and sustained effort over three months, diminishes the plausibility of the automatic writing hypothesis.

. . .

As an alternative, modern secular students of Mormonism have recourse to a repertory of explanations allowing for the plausibility of revelation without the necessity of giving up their secular orientation. I want to elaborate a bit further on Julian Jaynes's recent, controversial study, The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, in which he develops a theory of language and consciousness that also serves as an attempt to explain the origins of religion. According to Jaynes, though humans developed language about 100,000 years ago (the conventionally accepted theory), they did no evolve an inner life, or "consciousness," until about 2,000 B.C. Prior to that time, life was guided mostly by habit, as for example in ancient Egypt or pre-Homeric Greece. Humans lacked introspection, independent will, or the ability to perceive a past and a future. Gradually, as life became more complex and stressful, man responded through the development of inner voices which enabled him to gain control over a hostile world. The human brain evolved to accommodate these voices, assigning them to its right hemisphere, while reserving the left hemisphere to language. In a sense, the right hemisphere was giving instructions to the left. Jayne believes he has discovered an explanation for the role of religion in the development of ordered, structured societies.

"Bicamerality," however, began to break down sometime between the second and the first millennium B.C., as society became too intricate and complex to be governed by the relatively simple command of the "voices." More and more, man began to rely exclusively on the left hemisphere of the brain, with its highly developed potential for analytical language and rationality—or, in Jaynes's words, consciousness. "Man," says Jaynes, "became modern." Nevertheless, the transition has not been an absolute one. Stress, apparently, can work in opposite directions. While it played a significant part in breaking down bicamerality, it can also trigger restoration. In a stressful world such as ours, "most of us," says Jaynes, spontaneously slip back into something approaching the actual bicameral mind at some part of our lives." Others, less able to handle stress, relapse permanently, or for long periods, into the bicameral mind. In our society we label these people schizophrenics. Because auditory hallucinations are very common among schizophrenics, it has in fact been suggested that Joseph Smith may have suffered from this mental disorder. Yet Smith clearly did not exhibit any of the other symptoms of schizophrenia. Nevertheless, it is possible to fit him into the conceptual framework of Jaynes, who sees the transition from bicamerality to consciousness as far from complete. "All about us," he says, "lie the remnants of our recent bicameral past," in spite of the profound impact of Christianity, which began "as a necessarily new religion for conscious men rather than bicameral men" with its emphasis on an internalized ethic rather than a morality imposed by external authority. Yet he also points out that the history of Christianity has been a permanent struggle between a "longing for bicameral absolutes . . . [and] the difficult inner kingdoms of agape," with "an external hierarchy reaching through a cloud of miracle and infallibility to an archaic authorization in an extended heaven."

Mormonism appeared on the American religious scene at precisely that moment when external religious authority, both intellectually and institutionally, was in headlong retreat before the forces of individual responsibility and internal consciousness. For many Americans, accustomed to an older order of hierarchy and deference, the world was literally falling apart. In the words of Mario De Pillis, they began a "search for religious authority" or, in the words of Jaynes, for "archaic authorization." It was a time when many Americans began to ask: "Why are the gods no longer heard and seen?" Some of them demanded more assurances "than the relics of history or the paid insistences of priests. Something palpable, something direct, something immediate! Some sensible assurance that we are not alone, that the gods are just silent, not dead, that behind all this hesitant subjective groping about for signs of certainty, there is a certainty to be had." And it was in western New York, in the 1820s, that in the words of a famous Mormon hymn, "An angel from on high / The long, long silence broke." Thus, in Jaynes's hypothesis Joseph Smith—and people like him, who have visions, hear voices, and have dreams—can be explained as premodern individuals whose ability to use the right hemisphere of the brain far exceeds that of their more analytical and more modern contemporaries.

Jaynes's theory, admittedly, is highly controversial. Indeed, many academic psychologists, biologists, and religious scholars have expressed grave reservations about its validity. Nevertheless, even if we do not accept its physiological basis for psychological phenomena, we can use the concept of bicamerality as a metaphor that provides an imaginative and suggestive alternative framework for explaining the visions and revelations of Joseph Smith to those who cannot accept him as a "true" prophet in any objective sense, yet who do not wish to condemn him as an impostor, a charlatan, or a deluded fanatic.

Citations in Mormonr Qnas
Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.