William N. Goetzmann writes that JS may have heard about Hebraic Indian theories second or thirdhand from his environment.

Date
1985
Type
Academic / Technical Report
Source
William N. Goetzmann
Non-LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

William N. Goetzmann, “The Case of the Missing Phylactery,” Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society 95 (1985): 76-77

Scribe/Publisher
Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society
People
Ethan Smith, William N. Goetzmann, Fawn Brodie, Joseph Smith, Jr., Lucy Mack Smith
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

Ethan Smith's account is interesting because it represents a step towards the formation of a mythology about the phylactery, combining the story of the phylactery with the legend of a lost book in the possession of the Indians, and its burial in a hill with the body of a chief.

A View of the Hebrews went through two editions, in 1823 and 1825 and apparently enjoyed some local popularity in New England. Fawn Brodie, a biographer of Joseph Smith, asserts that the Mormon prophet took most of his ideas about the Israelites in America from A View of the Hebrews. Brodie speculates that Joseph Smith learned of the legend of the Pittsfield phylactery from Ethan Smith's book, for he quoted the Ethan Smith account in 1842, in Times and Seasons, the church newspaper published in Nauvoo, Illinois.

Did Joseph Smith's idea for The Book of Mormon come from having read A View of the Hebrews? Or did it come from the rumors, stories, and legends regarding ancient Hebrews in America, stories that were current in the early nineteenth century in New England and Upstate New York? Opponents of Mormonism throughout the last 150 years have pointed to a series of tenuous links between Joseph Smith and his associate Sidney Rigdon, and an unpublished fictionalized account of the ancient Hebrews in America, written by a man named Solomon Spaulding to prove that Joseph Smith borrowed the idea for The Book of Mormon from other sources. Brodie effectively disproved this popular explanation for the source of Joseph Smith's inspiration.

It seems likely that Joseph Smith could have heard secondor third-hand about the story of the Pittsfield phylactery as a young boy. There is ample evidence that, even as a child, Joseph Smith was fascinated by stories of Indians. For example. Fawn Brodie cites the account of his mother, Lucy Mack Smith that describes the young Joseph Smith's imaginative play-acting of Indian battles. Did the ten-year-old Joseph Smith hear about the Pittsfield find, and years later, perhaps even subconsciously, weave it into a story about the discovery of the golden tablets? Of course we will never know. However, the broad outline of a story of a Hebrew inscription found in a hill which proved the connection between the Indians and the ancient Hebrews closely resembles the tale Joseph Smith spun about his golden tablets. If the Pittsfield discovery was not a direct source of the Mormon legend, at the very least it contributed to the contemporary mythology that caused other writers to concoct tales about ancient historical manuscripts found in America.

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.