Gustav H. Blanke reviews the BOM in the context of Hebraic Indian theories of the 19th century.

Date
1980
Type
Academic / Technical Report
Source
Gustav H. Blanke
Non-LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Gustav H. Blanke, "Early Theories about the Nature and Origin of the Indians, and the Advent of Mormonism," Amerikastudien 25 (1980): 265–267

Scribe/Publisher
Amerikastudien
People
Ethan Smith, Elias Boudinot, Joseph Priest, Fawn Brodie, Joseph Smith, Jr., Caleb Atwater, Gustav H. Blanke
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

More joy would be set afloat, if Jewish messianism and Christian millennianism could be joined to American nationalism. One link was the rumor about the visit of the resurrected Christ to America. These rumors may have been started by the discovery of Christian crosses among the Indian ruins of South America. In 1802 the Cross of Cuzco became more interesting, when an anonymous patriot published an "authentic" letter written by Jesus to his ancient people in America. The publisher claimed that the letter had been found by an innocent child "under a great stone" in "Mesopotamia", Massachusetts.?' Though it is unlikely that Joseph Smith had occasion to see the rare item, it is likely that many people in the "burnt-over district" indulged their fancy in a similar way and that "the prophet Joseph" did not have to invent the American visit of the resurected Christ which occupies an important part in his book.

Many other events mayor may not have had an influence on the inception of Mormonism. To mention a few: In 1815 some alleged "Hebrew tablets" were found at Pittsfield, Mass. In 1816 the influential clergyman and statesman Elias Boudinot published a book about the near approach of the restoration of the house of Israel. During these years "archeologist" Caleb Atwater discovered more Indian mounds in Ohio. His Description of the Antiquities Discovered in the State of Ohio and the Western States (1820) repeated the conjectures about a Hebrew origin of Indian relics.

Fawn Brodie and other researchers are rather certain that Joseph Smith became acquainted with Rev. Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews (1823). A second edition came out two year later. Rev. Smith regarded his view as a crucial matter for all Christendom and for America in particular. The pastor was sure that the American Indians got their idea of the one God "Yo-he-wah", their notion of man as being created in his image, and sundry prophecies about man's redemption from the Hebrews. He also believed that the canoes made of rushes, which the Indians used on lake Titicaca, were similar to the ships once uses on the river Nile, and that the Indians had an "ark of the covenant" which contained the most sacred ritualistic objects. He devoted much space to the stories which the Indians had about the flood and the confusion of tongues. He commented on their "Hallelujahs", their council of twelve and on their "tabernacles" with twelve poles. "It is not pretended that all the savages are in the practise of all of these traditions. They are not. But it is contended that the whole of these things has been found among their different tribes [...].

A part of the book is devoted to the description of the Hebrew tablets found on Indian Hill. Ethan Smith stimulated the readers by asking questions which call for an answer: "Would evidence like the following be deemed as verging toward what would be satisfactory? Suppose a leading character in Israel - whereever they are - should be found to have had in possession some biblical fragment of ancient Hebrew writing. This man dies and it is buried with him in such a manner as to be long preserved. Some people afterward removing that earth, discover the fragment, and ascertain what it is [...]." Rev. Smith deplored that a colleague who had recognized the script as "Jewish phylacteries", had died in the meantime. But he was sure that some "holy scriptures" had been "providentially transmitted" to the American people in order to strengthen them in their mission to prepare the New Jerusalem on American soil. Rev. Smith also added a specimen of his prophecy by composing an "Address of the Prophet Isaiah, Relative to the Restoration of His people". Sixteen years before John O'Sullivan coined the phrase "manifest destiny" (1839), it was "manifest" to Rev. Smith (and probably to Joseph Smith also) that America was "destined" to take the lead, because the "Eastern parts of the world" had traditionally engaged in "anti-Christian hostilities". His Isaiah had seen it all and prophesied "a great nation"; "far sequestered from the seat of anti-christ, and of tyranny and blood" it would rise in the last days and establish itself as "a land of freedom and religion", an "asylum for equal rights". It would also bring about the unification of the tribes of Ephraim and Judah and finish the Restoration of Israel. All of mankind would find room under "the protecting wings of the great eagle"; "judgements shall be thundering through the nations of the Eastern continent", and they would be punished for having "trampled on the Jews".

A possible influence may have been Rev. Joseph Priest's A View of the Expected Christian Millennium (Albany, 1828), which restated the theory of Hebrew origins while putting more emphasis on the millennium. There was also a manuscript of a historical novel written by Rev. Solomon Spaulding. It dealt with the exodus of Romans to the New World. Other possible "sources" have been discussed. But perhaps nothing more was needed than 1) a quick responsiveness to what Thomas Browne had called "vulgar errors", namely widespread notions, dreams, and hopes based on faulty scholarship, 2) a high imagination and a lavish fancy, and 3) the perseverance of a devoted and ambitous young man who felt called to translate his visions into a convincing history of Indian tribes while at the same time offering a new version of the national covenant to backwoods people who waited for the light and who were ready to accept an original American contribution to the world of religion. Such a man could go far, even if his fiction was marred by the terribly pale human stereotypes of quasi-Biblical characters, by superfluous scenes of battle and slaughter, and by a poor imitation of Biblical style.

Joseph Smith denied having been influenced by anyone. According to his own story he felt a command to become "the voice of him that cryeth in the wilderness" (Isa 40: 30) and to prepare a highway for the Lord in the American "desert", where "the dried bones" of the lost tribes had been scattered for so many centuries. After purchasing the alleged Hebrew tablets he surprised his followers with the startling revelation that he had been commanded to translate the "golden tablets" which the angel Moroni had presented to him near the "Hill Cumorah", where the last of the "Nephites", the prophet Mormon, had buried these sacred records before he was killed in battle by his distant relatives, the cruel "Lamanites", from whom the modern Indian tribes were descended.

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.