Daryl Chase contrasts View of the Hebrews with the Book of Mormon in terms of the intent of each book.
Daryl Chase, Joseph the Prophet, as He Lives in the Hearts of His People (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1944), 127–129
Before the organization of the Church, men and women began to cluster around the youthful Prophet. The Book of Mormon which recently had issued from the local press at Palmyra discussed many questions which had vexed the minds of Americans from early Colonial times. Who were the Indians? Who had built the great mounds found in the Mississippi and Ohio Valleys? What people had buried the tools and utensils which the western farmers brought to the surface as they turned the great wilderness into fruitful fields and thriving villages? These, and other questions, it discussed. However , men and women did not uproot their economic and religious lives and follow the Prophet simply because the Book of Mormon testified that the American Indian was a descendant of the ancient Israelites. Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews or the Tribes of Israel in America (1825) and Elias Budinot's A Star in the West: or a Humble Attempt to Discover the Long Lost Ten Tribes of Israel (1816) had said the same, but their books did not change the course of human thought and action.
To the believers, the Book of Mormon was not just another book supporting the theory of the Hebraic origin of the American Indian. Here was "A New Witness for God." Here was new evidence that He was a personal reality and that His Son Jesus was still alive and had been the Messiah of the western hemisphere as well as of the eastern world. Through this volume ancient Christianity became reborn to multitudes. This book, which was destined to be translated into twenty-three different languages and have one and one-half million copies printed within a century this most influential book to be written in American resurrected and breathed new life into the greatest story of antiquity. It also disclosed that America was a chosen land, above all other lands, in the sight of the Almighty, and that on this continent men were to build a New Jerusalem, a Holy City, God's capitol of the western hemisphere where His Son Jesus Christ would eventually live in the midst of a righteous community.