David Pressley Bowman argues against the claim that the BOM is derived from VOTH.
David Pressley Bowman, I Have an Answer: A Powerful Reference Guide Concerning the Beliefs and Doctrines of the LDS Church (Springville, UT: Cedar Fort, 2003), 31–46
Question 3
Did Joseph Smith read a book called View of the Hebrews and from this book get enough ideas and facts about Indians to write The Book of Mormon?
Answer 3
Ever since the Book of Mormon was published in 1830 enemies have tried to find an explanation to its coming forth except for the real one. Joseph Smith did not write the Book of Mormon. The task of writing your own Book of Mormon is impossible. Like the examples written above computerized word analysis of the Book of Mormon unmistakably reveals separate Book of Mormon writers. The other very obvious point is that Joseph Smith received his vision from God the Father and Jesus Christ three years before the book View of the Hebrews was even written. Joseph Smith told others of this visitation and received persecution for it from the time he was fourteen years old. No one in the 1800s even questioned Joseph Smith about View of the Hebrews because they knew Joseph's claims occurred before. No one even brought up a similarity until the 1900s.
. . .
Making parallels is easy. Years ago, LDS Church leader B. H. Roberts made a list of the parallels between the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews. He did this as a preparation to defend the Church only. In all his reading he could only find around eighteen parallels. Nevertheless enemies of the LDS Church have attempted to use these parallels against the Church but they have been able to deceive very few. As mentioned above many of the parallels only appear to be similar to the Book of Mormon.
. . .
The claim has been made before, and has recently been raised again, that Joseph Smith specifically copied the main structure and many details in the Book of Mormon from Ethan Smith's 1823 View of the Hebrews. Alleged parallels between these two books have led some to esteem the Book of Mormon lightly, "as a thing of naught."
Since the alleged points of contact are scattered throughout View of the Hebrews and in some cases are claimed to be quite specific, this assertion becomes plausible only if we assume that Joseph knew View of the Hebrews quite well and implicitly accepted it as accurate. If he did so, then he should have followed it-or at least should have not contradicted it-on its major points.
But this does not turn out to be the case. Since several people have pointed out alleged ''parallels'' between the Book of Mormon and View of the Hebrews, consider the following ''unparallels'' that weaken, if not completely undermine, the foregoing hypothesis:
I. View of the Hebrews begins with a chapter on the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans. It has nothing to say, however, about the destruction in Lehi 's day by the Babylonians.
2. View of the Hebrews tells of specific heavenly signs that marked the Roman destruction of Jerusalem. Joseph Smith ignores these singular and memorable details.
3. Chapter 2 lists many prophecies about the restoration of Israel, including Deuteronomy 30; Isaiah 11, 18, 60, 65; Jeremiah 16, 23, 30-31, 35-37; Zephaniah 3; Amos 9; Hosea and Joel. These scriptures are essential to the logic and fabric of View of the Hebrews, yet, with the sole exception of Isaiah 11, none of them appear in the Book of Mormon.
4. Chapter 3 is the longest chapter in View of the Hebrews. It produces numerous ''distinguished Hebraisms'' as ''proof'' that the American Indians are Israelites. Hardly any of these points are found in the Book of Mormon, as one would expect if Joseph Smith were using View of the Hebrews or trying to make his book persuasive. For example, View of the Hebrews asserts repeatedly that the Ten Tribes came to America via the Bering Strait, which they crossed on ''dry land." According to View of the Hebrews, this opinion is unquestionable, supported by all the authorities.
From there View of the Hebrews claims that the Israelites spread from north to east and then to the south at a very late date. These are critical points for View of the Hebrews, since Amos 8: 11-12 prophesies that the tribes would go from the north to the east. Population migrations in the Book of Mormon, however, always move from the south to the north.
5. View of the Hebrews reports that the Indians are Israelites because they use the word ''Hallelujah." Here is one of the favorite proofs of View of the Hebrews, a dead giveaway that the Indians are Israelites. Yet the word is never used in the Book of Mormon.
Furthermore, a table showing thirty-four Indian words or sentence fragments with Hebrew equivalents appears in View of the Hebrews. No reader of the book could have missed this chart. If Joseph Smith had wanted to make up names to use in the Book of Mormon that would substantiate his claim that he had found some authentic western hemisphere Hebrew words, he would have jumped at such a ready-made list! Yet not one of these thirty-four Hebrew/Indian words (e.g., Keah, Lani, Uwoh, Phale, Kurbet, etc.) has even the remotest resemblance to any of the 175 words that appear for the first time in the Book of Mormon.
6. View of the Hebrews says the Indians are Israelites because they carry small boxes with them into battle. These are to protect them against injury. They are sure signs that the Indians' ancestors knew of the Ark of the Covenant! How could Joseph Smith pass up such a distinguished and oft-attested Hebraism as this?! Yet in all Book of Mormon battle scenes, there is not one hint of any such ark, box, or bag serving as a military fetish.
7. The Indians are Israelites because the Mohawk tribe was a tribe held in great reverence by all the others, to whom tribute was paid. Obviously, to Ethan Smith, this makes the Mohawks the vestiges of the tribe of Levi, Israel's tribe of priests. If Joseph Smith believed that such a tribe or priestly remnant had survived down to his day, he forgot to provide for anything to that effect in the Book of Mormon.
8. The Indians are Israelites because they had a daily sacrifice of fat in the fire and passed their venison through the flame, cutting it into twelve pieces. This great clue of ''Israelitishness'' is also absent from the Book of Mormon.
9. View of the Hebrews maintains that the Indians knew ''a distinguished Hebraism," namely "laying the hand on the mouth, and the mouth in the dust." Had Joseph Smith believed this, why is the Book of Mormon silent on this "sure sign of Hebraism" and dozens of others like it?
10. According to View of the Hebrews, the Indians quickly lost knowledge that they were all from the same family. The Book of Mormon tells that family and tribal affiliations were maintained for almost one thousand years.
11. View of the Hebrews claims that the righteous Indians were active "for a long time," well into recent times, and that their destruction occurred about A.D. 1400, based upon such convincing evidence as tree rings near some of the fortifications of these people. The Book of Mormon implicitly rejects this notion by reporting the destruction of the Nephites in the fourth century A.D.
12. View of the Hebrews argues that the Indians are Israelites because they knew the legends of Quetzalcoatl. But the surprise here is that View of the Hebrews proves beyond doubt that Quetzalcoatl was none other than-not Jesus-but Moses! "Who could this be but Moses, the ancient legislator in Israel?" Quetzalcoatl was white, gave laws, required penance (strict obedience), had a serpent with green plumage (brazen, fiery-flying serpent in the wilderness), pierced ears (like certain slaves under the law of Moses), appeased God's wrath (by sacrifices), was associate with a great famine (in Egypt), spoke from a volcano (Sinai), walked barefoot (removed his shoes), spawned a golden age (seven years of plenty in Egypt-which has nothing to do with Moses, by the way), etc. Besides the fact that the View of the Hebrews 's explanation of Quetzalcoatl as Moses is inconsistent with the Book of Mormon, none of these hallmark details associated with Quetzalcoatl are incorporated into the account of Christ's visit to Bountiful in 3 Nephi.
. . .
Question 5
Did Joseph Smith have access to the book View of the Hebrews at his local library?
Answer 5
It appears that Joseph Smith did not have access to the book View of the Hebrews at his local library. We know this because his local library required a fee and recorded the name of the person using the library. Neither Joseph Smith, nor any new member of the LDS Church at that time, had their names recorded. It is not surprising that Joseph is not listed as a patron considering the poverty his family was living in. The other point is that Joseph only had a third grade education and was not really into books. His mother said that Joseph, "seemed much less inclined to the perusal of books than any of the rest of our children, but far more given to meditation and deep study." By age eighteen, he still had not read the Bible all the way through.
. . .
Question 6
Oliver Cowdery was from the same hometown as Ethan Smith, the author of View of the Hebrews. Could Oliver have brought a copy of the book to Joseph Smith and then the two of them conspire to write the Book of Mormon?
Answer 6
There are several things that make the above theory impossible. Oliver was not Joseph Smith's first scribe, Martin Harris was. Thus, the Book of Mormon transcribing was already underway before Joseph even met Oliver Cowdery. The other point is that after Oliver finished as scribe and the Book of Mormon was published Oliver was actually excommunicated over some unrelated points and was thus kicked out of the Church. What a perfect time it would have been for an angry Oliver to expose Joseph Smith as a fraud but he did not.