Michael T. Griffith responds to arguments for the BOM's dependence on VOTH in an unpublished manuscript.

Date
1981
Type
Manuscript
Source
Michael T. Griffith
LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Reference

Michael T. Griffith, "The Book of Mormon As Ancient History: A Response to the Tanners, Larry Jonas, and Other Critics," unpublished manuscript, 1981, BYU HBLL, BX 8622 .G875b

Scribe/Publisher
Michael T. Griffith
People
Larry Jonas, Hugh W. Nibley, Michael T. Griffith, Ethan Smith, John L. Sorenson, Joseph Smith, Jr.
Audience
N/A
PDF
Transcription

Mr. Jonas thinks he has found the source for the earthquake described in 3 Nephi because he finds a sketchy description of an earthquake in Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews. (pp. 30-32.) However, Dr. Nibley has shown that the earthquake account in 3 Nephi is far too detailed to have been produced by anyone living in Joseph Smith's day.

. . .

In his attempt to account for the military fortifications described in the Book of Mormon by pointing out that descriptions of forts can also be found in Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews (p. 34). Mr. Jonas failed to mention the fact that the forts spoken of by Ethan Smith were built in North America hundreds of years after Book of Mormon times. On the other hand, Drs. Sorenson and Treat have demonstrated that ancient defensive fortifications amazingly like those described in the Book of Mormon have actually been found in Mesoamerica.

Mr. Jonas attempts to account for the similarities between Quetzalcoatl, the White God of ancient Mesoamerica, and Jesus Christ by pointing out the fact that Ethan Smith mentions Quetzalcoatl in the View of the Hebrews. (p. 34.) However, Ethan Smith thought that Quetzalcoatl was to be compared with Moses, not Christ. The fact that EthanSmith mentions Quetzalcoatl (as a type of Moses, not Christ) does not in any way explain away all of the complex parallels between the Quetzalcoatl legends and the Book of Mormon's account of Christ's visit to the Americas.

Apparently unbeknownst to Mr. Jonas (p. 39), the myth that Ethan Smith's account of a savage nation killing off a civilized one can be compared with the Book of Mormon's account of the Lamanites destroying the Nephites was completely exploded years ago by Dr. Nibley. Dr. Nibley pointed out that there exists nothing more than the most general of similarities between the two accounts and that there are many more significant differences. Furthermore, the civilizations which warred with each other in Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews lived in North America, not Mesoamerica. The final battles of the Nephites and the Lamanites did not take place in the state of New York; they were fought in southern Mexico. Therefore, it matters very little what Ethan Smith says about warring Indian nations in North America.

We are informed by Mr. Jonas (p. 39) that Ethan Smith "tells of a book preserved but finally buried with an Indian chief." Mr. Jonas then suggests that the Indian chief may have been Moroni! There are several problems with such a suggestion. For one thing, Ethan Smith was obviously talking about a book which was buried by some North American Indian tribe, not a Mesoamerican one. In addition, according to Ethan Smith's account, those Indians concluded that the book they buried "would be of no further use to them." (p. 41.) This can hardly be compared with the Book of Mormon's account of the burying of the Gold Plates, since the Gold Plates were thought by the Nephite prophets to be of priceless value. Furthermore, the Nephite prophets also believed that the Gold Plates would be of great worth to future generations. Interestingly, some of the histories of ancient Mesoamerica (which were not available to Joseph Smith) tell of a sacred book that was compiled by an ancient Mesoamerican "prophet" named Hueman. Even more interesting is the fact that Hueman, like Mormon, is said to have compiled his record shortly before his "death."

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.