Andrew H. Hedges positively reviews BYU's edition of View of the Hebrews and argues for little resemblance between it and the Book of Mormon.
Andrew H. Hedges, "Ethan Smith. View of the Hebrews.," Review of Books on the Book of Mormon 9, no. 1 (1997): 63–68
At first glance, the scene seems strangely incongruous: Brigham Young University's Religious Studies Center publishing a book that several generations of church critics have fingered as the true source of inspiration-rather than gold plates and the Urim and Thummim- for the Book of Mormon. The incongruity appears even more pronounced in li ght of the fact that, as the present edition's preface informs us, the book has not been republished since 1825, and copies are hard to come by. Why, one might legitimately ask, put what has been such a fruitful source of attack against the church back on the shelves now, just when it is on the verge of crumbling to dust? Is there a real need for a new printing of View of the Hebrews?
Indeed there is. One need only spend an afternoon reading through the most recent crop of books and essays dedicated to explaining away Joseph Smith and the church he restored as mere products of the nineteenth century to realize that the need for accessible copies of Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews has perhaps never been greater than at present. An afternoon thus spent would reveal the unfortunate fact that the increasing unavailability of this book has not been matched by an increasing scarcity of authors claiming that Joseph Smith borrowed, to one degree or another, from Ethan Smith's work when he "wrote" the Book of Mormon. Indeed, it is apparent from Charles D. Tate Jr.'s introduction to this new edition that the number of authors making this claim has been steadily increasing since I. Woodbridge Riley first propounded it in 1903 (p. ix). Given the 1825 edition's relative rarity, however, very few scholars-let alone laymen-who have wanted to compare the two books for themselves have had the opportunity to sit down with a complete, readable copy of Ethan Smith's work. Hence the present edition: the chance for anyone who is interested to decide for him- or herself "whether the claim that [View of the Hebrews] is a source of the Book of Mormon can be substantiated" (p. vii).
. . .
Thus it was that the further I read in View of the Hebrews, the greater the distance between it and the Book of Mormon appeared. Superficially, of course, the two resemble each other, and it was easy to see how someone with an ax to grind against the LDS Church could, with a little creative negligence, make a case against the Book of Mormon. But as I came to understand the complexity and inflexibility of Smith's model, it became increasingly clear to me that the Book of Mormon's teachings concerning Indian origins and destinies were something entirely new on the American scene and represented far more than mere modifications of the existing explanation. They were, to borrow a phrase, a "strange thing in the land" in every respect.
. . .
These two suggestions aside, I can only applaud the Religious Studies Center's willingness to publish View of the Hebrews. Not only has it made available an important primary source for those studying early Mormonism and its detractors, the center has, by publishing this book, demonstrated confidence in Joseph Smith's calling and mission as the prophet of the restoration, as well as in the divine origin of the Book of Mormon.