Robert D. Anderson suggests VOTH gave JS the "outline and concept" for the BOM and that Oliver Cowdery played a role in its conception.

Date
1999
Type
Book
Source
Robert D. Anderson
Critic
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Robert D. Anderson, Inside the Mind of Joseph Smith: Psychobiography and the Book of Mormon (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 1999), xi

Scribe/Publisher
Signature Books
People
Robert D. Anderson, Ethan Smith, Lyman Cowdery, Joseph Smith, Jr., Oliver Cowdery, Josiah Priest, John Hulbert Gilbert, B. H. Roberts
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

Unknown to most Mormons for more than half a century, LDS church leader, theologian, and philosopher Brigham Henry Roberts proposed a compelling alternative explanation for the Book of Mormon in the 1920s. Finally published in 1985 as Studies of the Book of Mormon, Roberts's thought-provoking analysis suggested that the book's general outline, as well as every major concept, had come from another book, A View of the Hebrews, published a few years earlier and written by Ethan Smith (no relation to Joseph Smith), a knowledgeable theologian of the day. A View of the Hebrews subscribed to the popular 400-year-old folk belief that Native Americans descended from the lost Ten Tribes of Israel. Roberts explored the legend in depth, noting the Book of Mormon's potential debt to Ethan Smith and identifying Joseph Smith's New World scripture as the most enduring representative of the theory that Native Americans were Israelites. Earlier in his life, Roberts had vigorously defended the Book of Mormon, but now his private analysis contained fierce irony, evidence of his expanding incredulity. In public he continued to champion the book's ancient historicity.

Even if the Book of Mormon derived its outline and concept from View of the Hebrews, what accounted for its detailed stories of miracles, conversions, heroism, visions, wars, prophecies, and teachings? Where did these stories come from? While brief forays into this area have been made by non-Mormons, there has been no comprehensive, consistent answer, despite a growing number of insightful naturalistic studies. One Mormon apostle dismissed such studies: "The practitioners of that approach typically focus on a limited number of issues, like geography or horses' or angelic delivery of nineteenth-century language patterns. They ignore or gloss over the increditble complexity of the Book of Mormon record."

. . .

OLIVER COWDERYS BACKGROUND

It is my opinion that Cowdery brought with him the over-arching conceptual plans and some of the important details that made it possible for Smith to complete the Book of Mormon. Cowdery's qualifications for teaching were minimal; in fact, Hyrum Smith as school trustee had actually hired Lyman Cowdery, who accepted the job, then urged them to accept his brother Oliver as his replacement. Oliver had worked as a blacksmith, farmhand, and store clerk; according to John Gilbert, the Book of Mormon's typesetter, he was not capable of correcting the grammar in the dictation. In the next nine to thirteen weeks, twenty-three-year-old Joseph Smith dictated to twenty-two-year-old Oliver Cowdery a book of 275,000 words; the printer, John H. Gilbert, who set its 588 pages, also corrected the grammar. It reached an estimated less than .1 percent of the population, at the effect was so profound that it changed American history.

. . .

Cowdery's second perspective was the Hebrew origins of the Native Americans. This interest, like the interest in magic, he also shared with Smith. In 1803 the Cowdery family, including seven-year-old Oliver, moved to Poultney, Vermont, in Rutland County, which shares a border with Windsor County, where Smith was born and lived for ten years. In Poultney, Oliver's stepmother joined the Congregational church in 1810 followed by his stepsisters in 1818. In 1821 Ethan Smith (no relation to the Joseph Smith family) became their pastor. Although there is no documentation that Ethan Smith and Oliver Cowdery had any kind of relationship, I argue that it requires more effort to believe they did not than that they did. As a consequence, I see Ethan Smith as the unwitting third man to help Joseph Smith produce the Book of Mormon by acting as an absent but necessary theologian.

In 1823 Ethan Smith published A View of the Hebrews; or The Tribes of Israel in America, which brought together writings by authors as far back as the sixteenth century promoting a popular belief of the day—that the Native Americans were the descendants of the lost ten tribes of Israel. Because of widespread interest, a second enlarged edition was printed in 1825. Ethan Smith visited Palmyra, perhaps in 1827, for the Wayne Sentinel printed notices that he should call at the post office for letters. The year after Ethan Smith's first edition appeared, Josiah Priest, whose works were a compilation of curious, dramatic, and historical items, printed fifty-six pages from Ethan Smith's book word for word in his own Wonders of Nature and Providence Displayed (Rochester, NY: n.p., 1824), only twenty miles from Palmyra, with a second edition following the next year." The Manchester library, five miles from the Smith home, owned a copy; and according to Robert Paul, it was repeatedly checked out in 1826-27, Hence it is highly likely—B. H. Roberts called it a "close certainty"—that Joseph Smith knew Ethan Smith's book, especially given the family's interest in pre-Columbian America. From a naturalistic perspective, I argue that Ethan Smith's book provided the concept and outline for much of the Book of Mormon. Although Ethan Smith was a distinguished theologian and successful author of the most influential book of the period promoting a Hebrew-Christian ancestry for the Native American, as well as being pastor to Cowdery's family, neither Cowdery nor Joseph Smith ever mention him. As a psychiatrist, I find this silence telling.

. . .

As I read the Book of Mormon, I see Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery constructing narratives of Joseph's personal life within Ethan Smith's conceptual framework, if not following the outline of his book. I also hypothesize that, dictating to Oliver Cowdery, who was ignorant of the similarities between Joseph's life and the narratives he was writing down, Joseph could be less restrained in fantasy than he had been with his wife or Martin Harris.

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.