Maurice C. Burrell follows Brodie in suggesting the BOM's dependence on VOTH.
Maurice C. Burrell, Wide of the Truth: A Critical Assessment of the History, Doctrines, and Practices of the Mormon Religion (London: Marshall, Morgan & Scott, 1972), 27–28, 34
On the question of the American Indians, it is interesting to see what Brodie says. She claims that at the time that The Book of Mormon was published, the most popular theory regarding their origin was that they were a remnant of the lost Ten Tribes of Israel. She maintains that there are striking parallelisms between The Book of Mormon and Pastor Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews which propounded this theory and she goes so far as to call Ethan Smith's book 'a basic source book for The Book of Mormon.' She comments that whereas Ethan Smith's book was just 'bad scholarship', The Book of Mormon was 'highly original and imaginative fiction". She adds that it is now established that these Indians originated in eastern Asia.
. . .
As we have seen, however, Brodie herself does believe that the twenty-five thousand words in The Book of Mormon which come from the Old Testament found their way into The Book of Mormon via Ethan Smith's View of the Hebrews.