Dale Morgan posits that VOTH and the BOM emerged in the same cultural context.

Date
1930 - 1950
Type
Book
Source
Dale Morgan
Disaffected
Critic
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Dale Morgan, "The Book of Mormon," in John Phillip Walker, ed., Dale Morgan on Early Mormonism: Correspondence & A New History (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 1986), 311–313

Scribe/Publisher
Signature Books
People
Ethan Smith, Solomon Mack, Dale Morgan, Joseph Smith, Jr.
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

Still, it is illuminating to see how suggestive the environment was, and to consider certain ideas which may have influenced not only the character of the Book of Mormon but the decision to write it. Nor must it be forgotten that Joseph was not the first in his family to undertake the writing of a book; Solomon Mack's little autobiography was one of the few claims to distinction which his family, during the years of Joseph's growing up, had possessed. While the paucity of information about Joseph Smith's early life is such that it cannot be proved that he had read any particular book, parallels between the book he eventually published and a popular historico-religious treatise of this decade are too striking to pass without comment. Pastor of a church in Poultney, Vermont, a few miles west of the area from which the Smith family migrated to New York in 1816, Ethan Smith published in 1823 a painstaking contribution to the theory that the American Indians were of Israelitish descent, and this book, View of the Hebrews; or the Tribes of Israel in America, was so well received as to have been reprinted in an enlarged edition two years later.

View of the Hebrews, like the Book of Mormon, espoused what in the 1820s was incomparably the most popular view of the origin of the American Indians, the theory of Hebrew descent. Ethan Smith conceived the Indians to be the remnant of the lost ten tribes of Israel; his young contemporary, whether from pure creative impulse or from a judicious appreciation of the dangers of getting beyond his depth, was content to present the Indians as the descendants of a few families who had come to America independently (though later he gratified the curiosity of his followers as to the Ten Tribes to the extent of explaining that they had taken up their residence in the vicinity of the North Pole). Otherwise Ethan and Joseph Smith were in cordial agreement with respect to the pre-Columbian history of the Americas. "It is highly probable," the Vermont minister theorized in words that anticipate the Book of Mormon in detail, "that the more civilized part of the tribes of Israel, after they settled in America, became wholly separated from the hunting and savage tribes of their brethren; that the latter lost the knowledge of their having descended from the same family with themselves; that the more civilized part continued for many centuries; that tremendous wars were fought frequently between them and their savage brethren, 'til the former became extinct. This hypothesis accounts for the ancient works, forts, mounds, and vast enclosures, as well as tokens of a good degree of civil improvement, which are manifestly very ancient. . . . These partially civilized people became extinct. What account can be given of this, but that the savages extirpated them after long and dismal wars?"

This theory, so congenial to the sentiments of a religious community which regarded the Bible as the ultimate frame of reference in which all human knowledge must be set, Ethan Smith supported with quotations from Humboldt and contemporary American antiquarians as to the existence in the New World of ancient fortifications, temples, and whole cities, and he argued at length the cultural evidences that the American Indians and the Ten Tribes were one. For three hundred years, ever since the discovery of America, those of scholarly bent and pious inclination had dissected the folkways and beliefs of the Indians for proofs of their Israelitish descent. The languages of the Indians, in actuality as widely dissimilar as those of the peoples of Europe or Asia, were listened to for Hebrew affinities and roots; ideas of a Great Spirit which the red men had picked up from intercourse with the whites were identified as a survival of Jewish monotheism; while the taboos, ritual purifications, and sacrifices, which have proved to be common to all primitive peoples everywhere, in this generation seemed conclusive proof of the identity of the Indians with ancient Israel. Ethan Smith dwelt upon the existence among the Indians of inspired prophets and gifts of the spirit, and did not fail to point out the similitude to the Urim and Thummim of the breastplate of an Indian medicine-man, "made of a white conch-shell with two holes bored in the middle of it, through which he puts the ends of an otter skin strap, and fastens a buck horn button to the outside of each, as if in imitation of the precious stones of the Urim."

View of the Hebrews made much of the destruction of Jerusalem, the scattering of Israel, and its promised gathering "in the last days," themes which are central to the Book of Mormon. Both books quoted extensively and almost exclusively from Isaiah, anticipating the literal fulfillment of Isaiahic prophecies; both conceived the American nation as the instrument by which Israel in America should be saved in the last days; and even the Book of Mormon's conception of a ministry performed by Christ in the New World is implicit in Ethan Smith's view of Quetzalcoatl, the dominant figure of Aztec mythology, as a "type of Christ."

As if these textual correspondences were not striking enough, View of the Hebrews reads almost like a manual of instruction for intending prophets, seers, revelators, and translators. If the Indians were of Israel, Ethan Smith declared, some decisive evidence of the fact would soon be exhibited. Suppose a leading character in Israel "should be found to have had in possession some biblical fragment of ancient Hebrew writing. This man dies, and it is buried with him in such manner as to be long preserved. Some people afterwards removing that earth, discover this fragment, and ascertain what it is—an article of ancient Israel. Would such an incident . . . be esteemed of some weight?" Ethan Smith could not-nor has anyone since been able to-furnish evidence so decisive for his thesis, but he related a story he had lately heard about an old Indian at Stockbridge, Massachusetts, who was reported to have given information "that his fathers in this country had not long since had a book which they had for a long time preserved. But having lost the knowledge of reading it, they concluded it would be of no further use to them; and they buried it:" Such things seemed now to be turning up; he himself had just barely failed to establish the whereabouts of certain parchments said to have been dug up in Pittsfield, reliably reported to be written in Hebrew. Ethan Smith was confident that some such discovery soon would be authenticated, and his reflections upon the significance of such a find for the redemption of the Indians are fully echoed in the Book of Mormon: "When God's bowels shall yearn for Ephraim! earnestly remembering him still, and about finally to restore him, it will prove that he has not been unmindful of that providential train of evidence, which must eventually identify a people long outcast and lost from the knowledge of the literary and civilized world, with his ancient beloved children of Abraham."

As impressive as are the parallels between View of the Hebrews and the concept and content of the Book of Mormon we need not insist upon them. It is more important that the ideas common to the two books should have been the common property of their generation. That this should be the character of Joseph's book, that it should exemplify as truly as View of the Hebrews a state of mind and a complex of ideas, the concepts of its time embedded in its pages like so many oysters in a stratum of limestone, is more significant in the evaluation of the Book of Mormon than any question of literary derivation, however decisive its bearing may be upon what the book claims to be. For, painful as such a finding may be to the sensibilities of those to whom the historicity of the Book of Mormon is a matter of the greatest importance, Joseph's book is a great deal more useful to a student of the intellectual preoccupations and the folkways of New York State in the third decade of the nineteenth century than to a scholar who would reconstruct the pre-Columbian history of America. In contrast to the often fascinating correspondences archaeologists have discovered between the Bible record and the early civilizations of the Near and Middle East during a century of intensive excavation in the New World the Book of Mormon has neither pointed to, accounted for, nor been illuminated by any find, while its central idea, the Hebraic origin of the American Indians, has been wholly exploded, and is given credence today nowhere outside Mormon seminaries. Yet from the beginning, the basis of the appeal of Joseph's book was that it constituted a record of the New World comparable in every respect to the biblical account of the Old. But if the materials directly borrowed from the Bible—its prophets, kings, and judges; its wrath and goodness of God—its silks fine-twined linens, chariots, and implements of brass and steel—were sifted out of the Book of Mormon, what remains would mirror only Joseph's own milieu, extending even to treasures hid up in the earth and made "slippery" by "sorceries and witchcrafts and magics."

BHR Staff Commentary

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.