Wesley M. Jones argues for the BOM's dependence on VOTH.

Date
1964
Type
Book
Source
Wesley M. Jones
Critic
Non-LDS
Hearsay
Direct
Secondary
Reference

Wesley M. Jones, A Critical Study of the Book of Mormon (Detroit: Harlo Press, 1964), 27–41

Scribe/Publisher
Harlo Press
People
Ethan Smith, Joseph Smith, Jr., Wesley M. Jones
Audience
Reading Public
PDF
Transcription

BRIEFLY, THIS WORK is a serious and well-documented essay support of a widely-held theory a century and a half ago, that the American aborigines are a remnant of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel, or "remnants of Ephraim." The Book of Mormon "translated" by Joseph Smith only eight years later, also makes a claim that aborigines (Lamanites) are blood descendants of Ephraim through the loins of Lehi their common ancestor, who fled Jerusalem in 600 B.C. The Book of Mormon treats the Ten Tribes as a separate branch of Israel still intact somewhere in the "north country." Otherwise, the two views run closely parallel.

. . .

In proving his thesis, Ethan draws most heavily Isaiah, and on Ezekial, Jeremiah, Amos, Hosea, Matthew and Paul to a lesser extent. It may be noted that the Book of Mormon makes use of the same prophets, with Isaiah far in the lead. Also, most of the texts used by Ethan are found in the sermons of the Book of Mormon. Therefore, when reading Ethan's work, many of these "voices" have a familiar ring to one who has studied the Book of Mormon. There is no question that Joseph Smith, also, was most familiar with the prophets of the OId Testament, especially Isaiah, for the Book of Mormon is interwoven with choice lines from that master. Also, the evidence mounts to show that Joseph was influenced greatly by Ethan's work.

. . .

The works of these Vermont Puritans are completely different. Ethan's is a well-thought-out thesis perhaps the work of a lifetime; a justification of a great movement, the restoration of the Lost Tribes of Ephraim. The Book of Mormon, whose basic ideas run closely parallel to those of Ethan's work and stem from it, is essentially a narrative, or history, interspersed with sermons by the Nephite prophets.

Copyright © B. H. Roberts Foundation
The B. H. Roberts Foundation is not owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.