Other Illinois lodges were disturbed about the number and quality of candidates initiated into the Nauvoo lodge.
John C. Reynolds, History of the M. W. Grand Lodge of Illinois, Ancient, Free, and Accepted Masons: From the Organization of the First Lodge Within the Present Limits of the State, Up to and Including 1850 (Springfield, IL: H. G. Reynolds, Jr., Masonic Travel Office, 1869), 199
"They have also examined the abstract returns of Nauvoo Lodge, U. D., and they find the work in some measure correct, but in many instances there appear irregularities, and matters to our committee inexplicable. The Lodge has failed to bring their record before the committee, which to some of your committee, at least, is a matter of surprise, knowing, as they do, the severe lesson the said Lodge was taught at the last Grand Communication. The greatest irregularitiy of which your committee would complain is, that there appears to be a disposition to accumulate and gather members without regard to character, and to push them on through the second and third degrees, before they can be possibly skilled in the first and second. Your committee are aware that there is no by-law of this Grand Lodge to prevent this; nor are they sure that any length of probation would in all cases insure skill; but they feel certain that the ancient landmarks of the order require that the Lodge should know that the candidate is well skilled in one degree, before he is advanced to another. Your committee will not doubt but there are many worthy and skillful brethren in Nauvoo Lodge; brethren who would under other circumstances be an ornament to the institution of Masonry; but they are reassured that their influence is entirely lost and obscured by the conduct of others less worthy; nay, of those who entirely disregard the ties that should bind us together as scared a band of friends and brothers.