Anonymous author criticizes the theory put forth in VOTH.
The Modern Traveller. North America, Vol. II (London: Oliver and Boyd, 1830), 251–252
. . . and coincidences still more remarkable, some of the most marvellous nature, have been adduced by other Travellers, in support of the romantic hypothesis which makes the American aborigines the descendants of the Ten Tribes of Israel.§
§ This quaint notion, first started by the Romish Missionaries, (who discovered the word Messiah in Mexico!) has found several advocates among Protestant writers; particularly Adair, the author of a "History of the Indian Tribes," who was for many years employed as agent among the North American Indians. In 1816, the Rev. Dr. Elias Boudinot, of New Jersey, published a volume entitled "A Star in the West, or an humble Attempt to discover the long lost Ten Tribes of Israel;” in which the same opinion was maintained. In 1825, appeared another volume on the same subject, by the Rev. Ethnan Smith, pastor of a church in Poultney, entitled, "View of the Hebrews, or the Tribes of Israel in America.” Of these two volumes, Mr. Israel Worsley has made copious use in his “View of the American Indians, shewing them to be Descendants of the Ten Tribes.” London, 1828. Still more recently, the hypothesis has found an enthusiastic advocate in a female Writer; “The Hope of Israel, &c., by Barbara Anne Simon.” 8vo. London. 1829. A critical account of these latter publications, and a refutation of the error on which the notion rests, will be found in the Eclectic Review, Aug. 1829, art. 2.