Lyman Copeland Draper criticizes the theory in View of the Hebrews.
Lyman Copeland Draper, ed., Collections of the State Historical Society of Wisconsin (Madison: State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1859; rep. 1906), 119
But the theory which traces them to the lost ten tribes of Israel, has found the most numerous advocates. Genebrard and Andrew Thevet were among the early advocates of this theory. It received a new impulse from Mayhew and Eliot, the New England missionaries to the natives. Thomas Thorogood published a book on the subject. The Earl of Crawford and Lindsay, a British officer in the war of the revolution, wrote in support of the same theory. Adair, Dr. Elias Boudinot, Rev. Ethan Smith, Lord Kingsbury and others, continued the train of zealous advocates of this view of Indian origin.
These writers collected some remarkable coincidences in respect to language, manners and customs, between the Indians and ancient Hebrews, and many more of a fanciful and puerile character, which, taken as a whole, are far from being conclusive when compared with other and more numerous facts of a contradictory nature.