Zadock Thompson provides history of the town of Poultney, VT; mentions Ethan Smith as pastor.
Zadock Thompson, History of Vermont, Natural, Civil, and Statistical: In Three Parts, With a New Map of the State, and 200 Engravings. Part Third. Gazetteer of Vermont (Burlington, VT: Chauncey Goodrich, 1842), 143–144
POULTNEY, a post town in the western part of Rutland county, is in lat. 44° 32' and long. 3° 54', and is bounded north by Castleton, east by Middletown and Ira, south by Wells, and west by Hampton, N. Y. It lies 60 miles southwest from Montpelier, 13 from Rutland, and 46 north from Bennington. It was chartered September 21, 1761, and contains about 35 square miles. The first proprietor's meeting was held at Sheffield, Mass., June 7, 1763. The settlement was commenced in 1771, by Thomas Ashley and Ebenezer Allen. The early settlers were mostly emigrants from Connecticut and the western part of Massachusetts. Heber Allen was first town clerk, and Wm. Ward first representative. The religious denominations are Congregationalists, Baptists, Methodists and Episcopalians, each of which has a good meeting house. That of the Congregationalists was erected in 1803, that of the Baptists in 1805, that of the Methodists more recently, and that of the Episcopalians in 1831. Rev. Ithamer Hibbard was the first settled minister. He was settled over the Congregational church in 1780, and dismissed July 7, 1796. His successors have been Rev. James Thompson from May 18, 1803, to 1820; Rev. Ethan Smith from Nov. 21, 1821, to December, 1826; Rev. Sylvester Cochrane from Oct. 24, 1827, to Oct. 13, 1834, and Rev. Solomon Lyman, the present pastor, settled Feb. 25, 1835. This society has funds to the amount of $5000. Elder Clark Kendrick was the first settled minister of the Baptist church. He was ordained in 1802, and died in March, 1824. Their present minister is the Rev. V. R. Hotchkiss. The Episcopal church, which bears the name of St. John's Church, consists of about 50 communicants. The Episcopal clergymen who have officiated here more or less are Rev. Bethuel Chittenden, Rev. Amos Pardee, Rev. Moore Bingham, Rev. Luman Foote and Rev. L. M. Purdy. Of the Methodist church we have no account. The epidemic in the spring of 1813, was very distressing, and in the course of three months was fatal to about 60 of the inhabitants. This township is watered by Poultney river and its numerous tributaries, which afford a number of valuable mill seats. The soil is generally warm and productive, and the surface pleasantly diversified with hills and vallies. Along Poultney river the alluvial flats are extensive and very productive. The timber is mostly deciduous, there being but few evergreens. A violent freshet, in July, 1811, swept off from the streams here four grist and four saw mills, one woollen factory, one carding machine, and several other buildings. There are two pleasant villages in Poultney, called East Poultney and West Poultney. East Poultney contains three houses for public worship, 3 stores, 1 grist and 2 saw mills, 1 iron foundry with machine shops, 10 or 12 mechanics, 1 tannery, 2 taverns, and about 60 dwelling houses. West Poultney contains a stone chapel, the Troy Conference Academy, a bank, 3 stores, 1 tavern, an extensive iron foundry, 52 dwelling houses and 312 inhabitants. The academy was projected at a meeting of the citizens, January 14, 1834; adopted by the Troy Conference of the Methodist Episcopal church September 3; chartered by the legislature of Vermont Oct. 25, and went into operation Sept. 1, 1836. The principal building is of brick, 112 feet by 36, with 4 principal stories, an attic and basement, and a rear 90 by 32 feet. The school is conducted by 4 male and 2 female teachers. (See part second, pages 180 and 184.) There are in town 15 school districts, 2 grain, 6 saw and several fulling mills, 5 stores, 4 taverns, and 3 tanneries. Statistics of 1840—Horses, 363; cattle, 2,098; sheep, 13,696; swine, 1,013; wheat, bus. 1,613; barley, 38; oats, 10,748; rye, 3,894; buckwheat, 1,283; Indian corn, 22,082; potatoes, 28,—724; hay, tons, 5,013; sugar, lbs. 10,765; wool, 34,946. Population 1,880.