Sarah Allen, writing in FAIR, critiques the CES Letter's comparison of The First Book of Napoleon to the Book of Mormon.
Sarah Allen, "Part 7: CES Letter Book of Mormon Questions [Section F]," FAIR Latter-day Saints, accessed July 14, 2026
THE FIRST BOOK OF NAPOLEON
Condemn not the (writing)…an account…the First Book of Napoleon…upon the face of the earth…it came to pass…the land…their inheritances their gold and silver and…the commandments of the Lord…the foolish imaginations of their hearts…small in stature…Jerusalem…because of the perverse wickedness of the people.
BOOK OF MORMON
Condemn not the (writing)…an account…the First Book of Nephi…upon the face of the earth…it came to pass…the land…his inheritance and his gold and his silver and…the commandments of the Lord…the foolish imaginations of his heart…large in stature…Jerusalem…because of the wickedness of the people.
At first glance, that seems pretty damning, right? Surely Joseph copied that over, because how could he not? This is so funny, though: that first paragraph from The First Book of Napoleon took 25 pages of the book to compile. The First Book of Napoleon is only 146 pages to begin with, according to the PDF of the book I linked to earlier. A full 1/6 of the book was used to recreate one incomplete paragraph of text taken from the Book of Mormon. Yet, we’re supposed to believe that this book is the inspiration for the Book of Mormon? Really? Come on.
But the problems don’t stop there. Take a look at the Book of Mormon paragraph:
Condemn not the (writing) [taken from the bottom of the title page] …an account [top of the title page] …the First Book of Nephi [title of 1 Nephi] …upon the face of the earth [1 Nephi 1:11] …it came to pass [1 Nephi 1:5] …the land [1 Nephi 2:11] …his inheritance and his gold and his silver and [1 Nephi 2:11] …the commandments of the Lord [1 Nephi 2:10] …the foolish imaginations of his heart [1 Nephi 2:11] …large in stature [1 Nephi 2:16] …Jerusalem [1 Nephi 2:13] …because of the wickedness of the people [1 Nephi 3:17].
Three chapters and the title page, 11 pages altogether, and it bounces all over the place. It’s most certainly not in order, and that order also doesn’t match the order they’re used in The First Book of Napoleon.
Also, the line about “Condemn not the (writing)”? That line from the Book of Mormon title page is actually, “…wherefore, condemn not the things of God, that ye may be found spotless at the judgment-seat of Christ.”